For decades, Brian May has been hailed as the genius behind Queen’s unmistakable sound, the soft-spoken scientist who built his own guitar, crafted anthems for generations, and helped keep Fredd.i.e Mercury’s legacy alive. But what if the harmony we saw on stage was only half the story? Behind the smiles, the camaraderie, and the thunderous applause, there was a hidden feud, a rivalry so intense it nearly tore Queen apart.
And the shocking part? It wasn’t with who you think. Tonight, we uncover the truth about the one bandmate Brian May secretly couldn’t stand, and the decades of silence that kept it buried. Brian Harold May was born on July 19th, 1947, in Hampton, Middlesex, England. His journey to rock stardom began far from the spotlight.
The son of a civil engineer father and a Scottish mother, he displayed remarkable intelligence from an early age. Gifted in physics and mathematics, he went on to earn a Bachelor of Science degree in physics from Imperial College London. But while his mind was set on science, his heart was already being pulled towards something else.
Music. From childhood, it was clear that Brian possessed not just brains, but an ear for melody. His parents noticed his perfect pitch early on, and in 1958, when he was just 11, they gave him a modest acoustic guitar for Christmas. He practiced endlessly, captivated by the sounds he could create.
His father, Harold, an engineer with a love for precision, admired his son’s dedication, but worried about the instability of a musician’s life. That clash, between logic and passion, safety and creativity, became the first of many internal conflicts that would follow Brian throughout his career. By his teenage years, May had already begun carving out his musical identity.
He formed his first band, 1984, named after George Orwell’s novel, and played covers at school dances. Even then, his perfectionism stood out. Friends from that time remembered him as meticulous. Someone who would rehearse a single song over and over until every detail was flawless.
Lacking money for professional equipment, Brian and his father decided to build their own guitar from scratch. Using wood from an 18th century fireplace mantel, motorcycle valve springs, and buttons from his mother’s sewing box, they created the now iconic Red Special. Finished in 1964, that handmade guitar would go on to define his sound and become one of the most recognizable instruments in rock history.
At university, May revealed another layer of his complex personality. He was brilliant, focused, and reserved, the kind of student who could calculate the stars by day and write riffs by night. A professor once described him as a scientist with the soul of an artist, a balance that would both enrich and complicate his later work with Queen.
In 1968, while still studying, May joined forces with drummer Roger Taylor to form a band called Smile. The two played small gigs around London, their music blending hard rock with a touch of the experimental. Then, in 1970, destiny arrived in the form of a flamboyant art student named Farrokh Bulsara, better known as Fredd.i.e Mercury.
After seeing Smile perform, Mercury proposed joining the group and suggested a new name, Queen. May was skeptical at first. He valued his musical chemistry with Taylor and wasn’t sure how Mercury’s theatrical presence would fit. But after one electrifying jam session, all doubts vanished.
Fredd.i.e’s four-octave range and magnetic charisma transformed everything. With the addition of bassist John Deacon in 1971, the classic Queen lineup was born. The early years were anything but glamorous. The four musicians lived together in a tiny London flat, scraping by on cheap meals while chasing an impossible dream. They were turned down by multiple record labels before finally signing with EMI in 1973.
Their debut album received mixed reviews, but critics immediately singled out May’s innovative guitar work. Despite the financial struggles, May would later describe this as one of the most joyful times of his life. At first glance, Queen looked like the perfect band, four brilliant musicians whose combined talents created something extraordinary.
Brian May’s intricate guitar work, Fredd.i.e Mercury’s operatic voice, Roger Taylor’s thunderous drumming, and John Deacon’s steady bass blended into a chemistry that felt untouchable. Their early albums hinted at greatness, but it was A Night at the Opera in 1975 and the release of Bohemian Rhapsody that sent them into the stratosphere of rock superstardom.
Yet, behind the brilliance of Bohemian Rhapsody lay the first signs of the creative tension that would later define them. Mercury came into the studio with an ambitious vision, one that pushed every technical and emotional limit. May, ever the perfectionist, spent weeks shaping his guitar parts to match that vision.
Advertisements
The now iconic operatic section required more than 180 hours of recording, with May, Mercury, and Taylor layering their voices for up to 12 hours a day. It was an exhausting process and not without conflict. May later admitted that he thought parts of the song were too operatic for a rock band.
Still, despite the arguments, the result was undeniable, a masterpiece that perfectly fused Mercury’s theatrical imagination with May’s meticulous craftsmanship. But success came at a price. As Queen’s fame grew, so did the cracks beneath the surface. While May often spoke publicly about his admiration for Mercury, insiders noticed the growing tension between him and John Deacon.
They were opposites in almost every way. May was analytical, detail-driven, and prone to bursts of emotion. Deacon was quiet, practical, and unyielding when it came to his ideas. The contrast became impossible to ignore during the recording of News of the World in 1977. May wanted to explore complex, layered arrangements, while Deacon pushed for simpler, radio-friendly songs.
In one notorious session at Wessex Studios, Deacon criticized May’s guitar solo on Spread Your Wings as too complicated, prompting May to storm out. Producer Mike Stone was forced to step in as mediator, while Mercury and Taylor left the room to avoid the escalating tension. The clash wasn’t just about sound.
It was about philosophy. May approached music like a physicist, constructing harmonies and arrangements with scientific precision. Deacon, an electronics graduate, favored clarity and efficiency, believing a song should say exactly what it needed to and nothing more. Even their lives began to mirror their creative divide.
By 1978, May was living like a rock scholar, buying a grand 19th century mansion in Surrey filled with antique telescopes and Victorian furniture. Deacon, on the other hand, remained grounded, living quietly in southwest London, driving a family car, and investing his money conservatively. Their differences finally came to a head with Another One Bites the Dust in 1980.
Written by Deacon, the song carried a strong disco influence, something May initially despised. During a tense meeting at Musicland Studios in Munich, he reportedly called the track disco trash and tried to block its release. But Mercury sided with Deacon, championing its groove and commercial potential. The song went on to become one of Queen’s biggest hits, selling over 7 million copies and topping charts around the world.
It was a massive victory for Deacon and a quiet blow to May, whose musical instincts had been overridden. The success deepened the unspoken divide between the two men. One of the most telling signs of tension surfaced during a 1979 interview that’s now mostly forgotten. When asked about his bandmates, Brian May warmly praised Fredd.i.e Mercury’s creativity and Roger Taylor’s drive, but hesitated when John Deacon’s name came up.
After a brief, awkward silence, he forced a smile and said, “John keeps us grounded.” Watching the old footage today, the discomfort is unmistakable. By the early 1980s, that unease had hardened into open friction. During the Hot Space sessions in 1982, Queen’s most disco-inspired album, May and Deacon barely spoke.
Producer Reinhold Mack later admitted they often recorded on different days to avoid being in the same room. May disliked the album’s funk direction, heavily shaped by Mercury and Deacon, and their dispute over the song Back Chat nearly broke the band. May wanted a heavier guitar presence.
Deacon insisted on keeping it minimal. The argument escalated until May threatened to quit, forcing Mercury to step in and broker a fragile compromise. The strain was made worse by May’s personal life. His marriage to Christine Mullen was falling apart, and he struggled with depression. In a 1983 Record Mirror interview, he confessed to feeling lost and uncertain about his place in Queen.
Friends recalled him retreating to his hotel room after shows, avoiding parties, and withdrawing from the group. Things exploded again in 1984 during The Works Tour. After a controversial concert in Sun City, South Africa, which defied the anti-apartheid boycott, May and Deacon clashed backstage. Witnesses said Deacon accused May of caring more about his guitar solos than the ethics of performing there, prompting May to snap and call him soulless.
Mercury and Taylor had to physically separate them. For weeks afterward, the two men refused to speak, communicating only through assistants and standing on opposite sides of the stage. Mercury eventually lost patience, telling them both to grow up or get out, an ultimatum that kept Queen from imploding. Publicly, they maintained a polished image.
May complimented Deacon’s songwriting, and Deacon acknowledged May’s genius. But insiders knew the truth. Their relationship was strictly professional. One longtime crew member called it arctic at best. The rift reached its height during the making of The Miracle in 1989. With Mercury’s health quietly deteriorating, the band decided to credit all songs collectively to Queen to ease tensions.
Yet May and Deacon were still at odds over the band’s creative direction. During the recording of I Want It All, a powerful guitar-driven anthem typical of Brian May’s style, the long-simmering tension within Queen finally boiled over. According to producer David Richards, John Deacon deliberately played out of time during one take, frustrating May to the point of confrontation.
When May demanded an explanation, Deacon reportedly shot back, “Not everything has to be about your guitar.” Fredd.i.e Mercury, already frail from illness, broke down in tears watching his bandmates fight. The moment stunned everyone into silence, a painful reminder of how fractured the group had become. What few fans knew was that May was battling his own private darkness at the time.
His marriage was collapsing, and the weight of fame, grief, and constant conflict pushed him to the brink. In a 2002 Guardian interview, he admitted that during those years, he would sometimes sit alone in his car outside the studio for hours, unable to bring himself to go inside. Deacon, on the other hand, retreated into himself, weary of the industry and deeply worried about Mercury’s deteriorating health.
While May coped through relentless work, Deacon turned his focus to his family and financial stability, quietly preparing for life beyond the band. One of the most poignant moments between them came during the video shoot for These Are the Days of Our Lives in May 1991. Mercury’s illness had progressed, though it was still hidden from the public.
Between takes, May stayed close to Fredd.i.e, adjusting his costume and offering support. Deacon kept to the background, silent and withdrawn. The director later recalled that it wasn’t indifference. It was heartbreak. Deacon simply couldn’t face how ill Mercury had become. When Mercury d.i.ed that November, Queen would never be the same.
At the 1992 tribute concert, May and Roger Taylor took the spotlight while Deacon quietly kept to the edge of the stage, a dynamic that continued in the years that followed. May and Taylor carried Queen’s name into new projects, while Deacon faded from public life. After Mercury’s funeral, May reached out in hopes of mending their fractured relationship.
Deacon’s reply was brief and final. Without Fredd.i.e, there is no Queen. The words cut deeply, and from that point, their friendship never recovered. The final break came in 1997 during the recording of No One But You, Only the Good Die Young, the last song to feature all three surviving members. When May suggested changes to Deacon’s baseline, Deacon snapped, “This is the last time you’ll ever tell me what to play.
” He packed up his instrument, walked out, and soon after announced his retirement. He would never perform with Queen again, declining even to attend their 2001 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction. Over time, May’s public comments about Deacon grew increasingly distant. In a 2014 Rolling Stone interview, he admitted, “We don’t have any contact with John.
He doesn’t want to be in that arena anymore.” Four years later, he referred to Queen as “the three of us,” meaning himself, Taylor, and Mercury, leaving Deacon’s name unspoken. What makes this story remarkable is how well they concealed their conflicts from fans. Unlike the Beatles or the Eagles, Queen never aired its feuds in public.
Yet hints of strain have surfaced in later years, including leaked A Kind of Magic outtakes where May can be heard saying, “If he changes my arrangement one more time, I’m walking out.” The he was unmistakably Deacon. Perhaps Fredd.i.e Mercury summed it up best. In one of his final interviews in 1991, he joked, “Darling, we’re all married to each other, and like any marriage, sometimes you want to kill your spouse.
” When asked about May and Deacon specifically, he smiled sadly and said, “They’re like fire and ice. Brian burns hot. John freezes over. It creates steam, and steam powers engines. That’s Queen.” At 78, Brian May remains a force of nature, still touring the world with Queen plus Adam Lambert, holding a PhD in astrophysics, and even earning a knighthood in 2023.
In recent years, he’s spoken of John Deacon with a touch more warmth, sometimes expressing hope for a reunion. But those close to the band quietly admit it’s unlikely ever to happen. Now 74, Deacon lives a quiet, almost invisible life in southwest London. He hasn’t appeared publicly in more than two decades and keeps little contact with his former bandmates.
Locals sometimes spot him at a pub or on a quiet walk, but he never talks about Queen. His son once revealed that Deacon rarely even listens to music anymore, as if he’s shut that chapter of his life completely. In his home studio, May keeps a photo of the original Queen lineup, a small, silent tribute to what they achieved together.
In a 2022 documentary, when asked about Deacon, May paused and said softly, “I wish things had been different. We made magic together, even when we could barely stand to be in the same room.” And so, behind Queen’s thunderous anthems and legendary performances, lay a story few ever knew, one of genius, rivalry, and unspoken resentment between two men who helped shape rock history.
Time may have healed some wounds, but the silence between Brian May and John Deacon still lingers like a final, unresolved chord. What do you think? Was their tension a secret ingred.i.ent that made Queen’s music so powerful, or the tragedy that tore them apart? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to like, subscribe, and stay tuned for more untold stories.
