October 1956, Memphis, Tennessee. Ellis Auditorium, backstage corridor. 11:45 at night. A 21-year-old man named Elvis Presley stands outside a closed dressing room door and raises his hand to knock and then does not knock. He has been standing here for 4 minutes. He played two shows tonight.
The first at 8, the second at 10:30. Both sold out. The screaming started before he reached the microphone and did not stop until he was back in the car. He is 21 years old and he has been famous for approximately 14 months and he still does not entirely know what to do with the screaming. Not because it frightens him, but because it exists in a register that has nothing to do with the music.
And he came to Memphis at 17 to make music. And the screaming is something else. Something that has attached itself to the music and will not be detached. And that he is learning to live alongside the way you learn to live alongside something that is not going away. He is not here about the screaming.
He is here because of something he heard 3 weeks ago on the radio in the tour bus between Shreport and Baton Rouge at 2:00 in the morning when most of the other men on the bus were asleep. He heard a voice come out of the radio that did something to him that very few voices had ever done, which was make him feel that the person singing was not performing a song, but stating a fact, a hard fact.
The kind of fact that cost something to say out loud. The voice was low and deliberate, and it carried something in it that reminded him of the preachers he had heard in the Assembly of God churches in Tupelo when he was a boy. the ones who were not performing their faith but living inside it. And the song was Fulsome Prison Blues, and the man singing it was Johnny Cash, and Elvis Presley had listened to it twice, and then sat with the window open in the Louisiana night coming in and thought about it for a long time. He has been thinking about it for three weeks. The door in front of him belongs to Johnny Cash’s dressing room. Cash played the first show on the bill tonight before Elvis, which is not the usual order of things, but which the promoter had arranged for reasons of scheduling. Elvis had been in his own dressing room during Cash’s set and had heard it through the wall and then had stood in
the wing for the last three songs, watching from the side of the stage, which nobody had told him to do, and which he had done anyway, because the voice through the wall had pulled him out of his chair and down the corridor without his entirely deciding to go. He had watched from the wing.
Cash had not seen him. And now the show is over and Elvis is standing outside Cash’s dressing room door with his hand raised and not knocking. Here is what Elvis Presley is about to say when he finally knocks on that door. He is about to say the thing that 21-year-olds almost never say to anyone, especially not to other performers, especially not backstage after a show where the screaming has been going on for 2 hours.
He is about to say, “I don’t know what I’m doing. I have something, but I don’t know what it is or how to use it or whether it’s going to last. And when I heard you sing tonight, I understood something I haven’t been able to understand. And I need you to tell me what you know.” He does not know yet how Cash will receive this. He knocks. Here is the story.
Johnny Cash was 24 years old in October 1956. He had been recording at Sun Studio for 2 years. Folsome Prison Blues had come out in 1955 and I Walked the Line had come out in April 1956. And both of them were on the charts. And Sam Phillips had been right about what he had when Cash walked into Sun and opened his mouth.
Cash was not yet the man in black in the full sense of that identity was still becoming it. Still finding the edges of what he was and what he was not. But the voice was already completely itself. Had been completely itself since the cottonfield in Das. And the audiences he was playing to in late 1956 understood that they were hearing something that was not quite like anything else.
He was sitting in his dressing room after the show with a Coca-Cola and his guitarist, Luther Perkins, when the knock came. Luther opened the door. Elvis Presley was standing in the corridor. Cash looked at him. He knew the face. Everyone in Memphis knew the face by October 1956. He had heard Elvis on the radio. He had a specific opinion about what he heard, which was that the boy had something genuine under the performance, something that connected to the same root system as what Cash was doing, though they were drawing from it differently and in different directions. He said, “Come in.” Elvis came in. He looked at the room, which was a small dressing room with two chairs in a mirror and Luther Perkins sitting in the corner with a guitar across his knees. He looked at Cash. He said, “I heard you from the wing the last three songs.” Cash said,
“I know. I saw you.” Elvis stopped. He said, “You saw me.” Cash said, “I looked over twice. You were there both times.” Elvis was quiet for a moment. Then he said, “I’ve been thinking about something you do. Something I heard on the radio three weeks ago. Folsome prison blues. the way you sang it.
I’ve been trying to figure out what you’re doing that I’m not doing. Luther Perkins looked at Cash. Cash looked at Elvis. Cash said, “Sit down.” Elvis sat in the empty chair. “Where are you watching from? Drop your state or country in the comments. I want to know how far this story reaches.
” What followed was not a master class. It was not a mentor dispensing wisdom to a student. It was two young men from the South sitting in a small dressing room after a show talking about the only thing either of them cared about with the complete honesty that is available at 21 and 24 when you are not yet famous enough to be careful about what you reveal.
Advertisements
Cash said, “What do you think you’re not doing?” Elvis said, “You sing like you mean every word, not like you’re performing the meaning. Like the meaning is already there and the words are just how it comes out. When I sing, I can feel myself performing it sometimes. I can feel the distance between me and the song.
” Cash looked at him for a long moment. He said, “Where are you from?” Elvis said, “Tupelo, East Tupelo.” Cash said, “I’m from Das, Arkansas. Do you know what DAS is?” Elvis said, “Delta.” Cash said, “Delta cotton. You know what cotton is?” Elvis said, “Yes.” Cash said, “Then you know what I’m singing about when I sing Flesome Prison Blues.
Not the prison specifically. The feeling of watching something go by that you’re not on. The train in that song is everything that’s moving in the world and you’re standing still watching it. Every person who grew up picking cotton in the Delta knows that feeling from the inside. I’m not performing it.
I lived it. I’m reporting it. Elvis was quiet. Cash said, “What are you reporting?” Elvis looked at him. He said, “I don’t know yet.” Cash said, “That’s the problem. And that’s also not a problem. You’re 21. I’m 24. Neither of us knows yet. But here’s what I can tell you. The thing that makes a voice real is not the technique.
It’s the thing you’re carrying that has nowhere else to go except into the song. You’ve got something you’re carrying. I can hear it. You can hear it, too, or you wouldn’t be sitting in this room asking me about it. Elvis said, “How do you find it?” The thing you’re carrying. Cash said, “You stop trying to find it. It finds you, but it can only find you if you stop moving long enough for it to catch up.
All the screaming, all the shows, all the road, that’s noise. The thing that’s real is underneath the noise. You have to be quiet enough to hear it. Elvis looked at his hands. He said, “I don’t know how to be quiet. I’ve never been quiet. Even before the shows, before any of this, I was always moving.” Cash said, “I know. I was too.
I still am. But there are moments on stage. Sometimes between songs, there’s a second where everything goes quiet and the next thing hasn’t started yet. That second is where the real thing lives. You have to learn to find it and stay in it long enough for the song to come from it instead of from the performance.
Luther Perkins had stopped pretending to tune his guitar. He was listening with the focused stillness of a man who understands he is in a room where something worth hearing is happening. Elvis said, “I walked the line. I heard it when it came out. I must have played it 20 times.
There’s something in it that I can’t find anywhere else. It sounds like a man making a promise to himself as much as to anyone else. Like he’s reminding himself of something he knows he needs reminding of.” Cash said, “That’s exactly what it is.” Elvis said, “Did it work?” The reminding Cash was quiet for a moment.
He said, “Some days.” That answer, those two words, “Some days,” landed in the room with the weight of complete honesty. The weight of a 24 year old man telling a 21-year-old man the truth about the distance between what you sing and what you live which is not always the same distance and which changes depending on the day and the road and the particular quality of the darkness you are carrying at any given moment.
Elvis looked at him. He said, “I needed to hear that. I’ve been around people for 14 months who tell me everything I do is perfect. It’s like living in a room with no mirrors. I can’t see myself at all. Cash said, “The mirrors are in the music. The honest ones. You’ll find them, but you have to be willing to look at what they show you.” They talked for another hour.
Luther eventually excused himself, and the two of them stayed in the small dressing room with the mirror, the two chairs, and the remains of Cash’s Coca-Cola. and talk the way young men talk when they have found someone who understands the specific thing they are trying to understand.
They talked about Tupelo and Das and what the radio had meant to each of them as boys, the specific voices that had come through it that had changed the direction of things. They talked about Sam Phillips who had recorded both of them at Sun and who understood something about the relationship between a voice and a microphone that neither of them could fully articulate but both had experienced.
They talked about the road and what it did to a person and what it cost and how you kept the thing that was real from being worn down by the thing that was performed. At 1:00 in the morning, Elvis stood up. He said, “I need to go. The colonel will be looking for me. Cash stood up. They shook hands. Elvis said, “Thank you. I mean it.
I don’t have people in my life I can say this kind of thing to.” Cash said, “You will find them and keep them.” Elvis said, “How do you know who they are?” Cash said, “They’re the ones who tell you some days instead of every day.” Elvis almost smiled. He said, “I’m going to remember that.” He went to the door.
He stopped. He turned back. He said, “I walk the line. Is it hard to sing every night? The promise in it? Is it hard to keep delivering it?” Cash said, “Yes.” Elvis nodded. He said, “Good. I think it should be hard. I think the ones that are easy aren’t worth singing.” He went out the door and down the corridor and back to his own dressing room in the colonel in the machinery of being Elvis Presley in October 1956.
Cash sat back down in his chair. He finished his Coca-Cola. He looked at the closed door. Now June Carter Cash June was not in Memphis that night. She and Cash were not yet together in the way they would be together. We’re still in the long years of orbit. the circling that would last until 1968. But June knew Cash well enough by 1956 to know something had happened when he called her from the hotel that night.
And she could hear it in the specific quality of his voice. The quality it had when something had found its way through the noise to the real thing underneath. She asked, “Good show?” He said, “Good show and something else?” She said, “Tell me.” He told her about Elvis in the corridor and the four minutes of not knocking in the dressing room and the two hours in some days.
He told her what Elvis had said about the mirrors. He told her what Elvis had said at the end about the ones that are easy not being worth singing. June was quiet for a moment. Then she said, “He’s right about that.” Cash said, “I know.” June said, “Is he going to be all right?” Cash thought about it.
He said, “I don’t know. He’s got something real. Whether it survives what’s happening to him is a different question.” June said, “What’s happening to him?” Cash said, “The same thing that happens to all of us. The noise gets louder and the quiet gets harder to find. He’s 21 and the noise is already enormous.
” June said, “But he came and knocked on the door.” Cash said, “Yes.” June said, “That’s the thing, John. That’s the whole thing. He knew to knock on the door. Most of them don’t know that. Most of them just live in the noise until it’s all there is.” Cash said, “Yes.” June said, “So, he’s going to be all right.
” Cash did not answer directly. He said, “I hope so.” He meant it. He would go on meaning it for the next 21 years through the trajectory of Elvis’s career and the darkness that ran alongside it and the years when the noise became everything and the quiet became impossible to find. He watched from a distance the way you watch someone whose situation you understand and cannot change with a specific helplessness of a man who has said the true thing and knows that saying the true thing is all that was available and that what happens after is not in his hands. They ran into each other at shows and on Music Row and in the corridors of the industry over the years. They were never close in the way that people who spend time together are close. But there was something between them that had been established in a dressing room in Memphis in October 1956.
A mutual recognition of what the other person was carrying and what it cost and where it came from. The recognition that you get when you meet someone who grew up in the same flood plane, who heard the same radio through the same thin walls, who understands from the inside what you mean when you say delta and cotton and the feeling of watching something go by that you’re not on.
Elvis Presley died on August 16th, 1977. He was 42 years old. Cash heard the news in Hendersonville. He did not make a public statement that day. He went quiet the way he went quiet when something required sitting with rather than speaking about. He sat with it. He thought about a 21-year-old standing in a corridor outside a closed door for 4 minutes and then finally knocking.
He thought about some days. He thought about the ones that are easy not being worth singing. He thought about whether Elvis had found the people who told him the truth. whether the quiet had ever been findable in the years when the noise became what it became. Whether the mirrors had been available, whether the real thing had survived.
He did not know the answers to these questions. He had only the questions in the memory of a dressing room in Memphis and two young men from the south talking about the only thing that mattered to either of them with the complete honesty that is available before the noise gets too loud.
The ones that are easy are not worth singing. Elvis knew that at 21. He said it out loud in a dressing room at Ellis Auditorium, and Cash heard it and recognized it as the truest thing either of them had said all night. Whether knowing it was enough is the question that does not have an answer. Cash kept singing the hard ones.
Every night, some days. If this story reached you, leave a comment. Tell me where you are watching from. Tell me if there is someone in your life who told you the true thing instead of the easy thing. The way Cash told Elvis in that dressing room. Those people are worth more than they know. Hit the like button if this is the kind of story you want more of and subscribe so you are here when the next one comes.
We are not done
