Sonoita Valley, Arizona, 1956. He said it on a Wednesday morning in August, standing at the fence line between the Hollister property and the road, watching her hang shirts in the sun. He hadn’t planned it. He hadn’t rehearsed it. It came out the way true things sometimes do, before better judgment could stop them.
“You know, May, whoever ends up marrying you is going to be a very lucky man.” He expected a laugh, a modest deflection, the kind of response that lets everyone move on without anyone having to be brave. Instead, she went still. Her hands stayed on the shirt she was pinning. A color came into her face slowly, like a lamp being turned up.
She didn’t look at him immediately. Then she did, and her expression was something he had never quite seen on her before, open and afraid and decided all at once. And she said, very quietly, “I was hoping it would be you.” The cottonwood at the corner of the fence made its sound in the August wind. The shirts on the line moved.
A hawk crossed the sky above them without hurrying. He stood on his side of the fence and understood that something had just been said that could not be unsaid, and that he was not entirely sure he wanted it unsaid. He was 49 years old. He had spent 30 years playing men who were certain. He was not certain of much that morning in Sonoita Valley, but he was certain of this.
John Wayne had come to Sonoita Valley in the first week of August because the second unit on the Hondo interiors had wrapped 2 weeks early, and he had 10 days that belonged, for once, to no particular schedule. He had driven south from Tucson on a road he had taken once before and remembered liking through the high grassland country where the mountains came up out of the valley floor differently from anywhere else.
He had rented a room from Roy Hollister because Hollister had good horses and the good sense to leave a man alone. He had rented from Hollister once before, two years earlier, during a stretch between pictures. He remembered the horses and the silence and the quality of the morning air in the San Rafael Valley.
He had called ahead from Tucson. Hollister had said, “Come on.” Roy Hollister was 61 years old, a lean and deliberate man who had ranched the Sonoita Valley for 30 years and who had the particular manner of someone who knew the difference between talking and saying something. He had a daughter named Margaret, who everyone called May, who was 26 years old and who had been running the Hollister house since her mother died in 1951.
Wayne had met May briefly on his first visit 2 years earlier. He remembered her the way you remember someone who made a competent impression. The house was ordered, the meals were good, the whole operation ran with the quiet efficiency of someone who has thought carefully about how things should work.
He had not thought about her between that visit and this one, which, in retrospect, was information about how well he had been paying attention. He arrived on a Sunday evening. Hollister was on the porch. May showed him to the same room he had used before, back of the house, east-facing window. “Supper at 6:00,” she said.
She went back to the kitchen. Supper was pot roast and bread and a conversation about cattle prices in Santa Cruz County that Wayne found genuinely interesting. May had opinions, considered, offered without insistence. She was right about two things he knew enough about to assess. Hollister ate and listened and added two words every 10 minutes, which was his rate in all conversations.
After supper, Wayne sat on the porch with his coffee and Hollister with his pipe. And the evening came down over the valley the way evenings came down over Sonoita Valley. And Wayne thought this was one of the better porches he had sat on. He did not think about May. He thought about the horses he would ride in the morning and whether the hawk he had seen on the drive in was a Cooper’s or a sharp-shinned.
He went to bed early and slept well, which had not been happening reliably in Tucson. On Monday morning, he rode north along the valley. On Tuesday, he rode east toward the mountains. On Wednesday morning, he was riding back along the fence line that marked the boundary between the Hollister property and the county road when he saw her at the clothesline between the house and the cottonwood.
She was working quickly the way she did everything. Basket at her feet, shirts going up one after another. Sleeves rolled to the elbow, hair pinned up practically. She was humming something low, barely audible over the cottonwood. He pulled the horse up. He had not planned to stop. But the horse slowed and he let it.
And he sat there without particular intention and watched her work. She noticed him. She raised a hand. He raised his in return. “Morning,” she said. “Morning.” She went back to the basket. He stayed on the horse. The wind moved through the cottonwood. He thought about the hawk from yesterday and about the Hondo footage that was waiting for him in Tucson and about nothing in particular and his horse stood still in the August morning sun and did not seem to be in a hurry either.
Advertisements
She was hanging the last shirt when she said, without looking up, “You ride that fence line every morning.” He said, “It’s a good fence line.” She looked at him then. There was a dry note in it, that particular humor of hers that arrived without announcement. He rode back to the barn. He unsaddled the horse. He went in for coffee.
May was at the kitchen table with a ledger, writing something in her neat, even hand. He poured his own coffee because the pot was right there and she was working. She didn’t look up. He sat down at the other end of the table and drank his coffee and looked at nothing in particular. After a while she said, without looking up from the ledger, “Papa says you were on a picture in Tucson.
” He said, “Yes.” She said, “What kind?” He told her about the Hondo interiors, about the set and the schedule and the particular logistical problem of shooting a desert picture on a studio lot. She asked two questions that were better than the questions most people asked and he found himself giving fuller answers than he usually gave.
She went back to the ledger. He finished his coffee. He was halfway to the door when she said, “Supper’s at 6:00.” He said he’d be there. He was there at 5:50, which was the first time in years he had been early to anything that didn’t have a call sheet attached to it. Where are you watching from? Drop your state in the comments.
I want to see how far this one reaches. The week went on. He rode in the mornings and came in for coffee. And sometimes May was at the kitchen table with the ledger. And sometimes she wasn’t. Hollister had fence work in the north pasture and Wayne spent two afternoons helping with it. Not because he was asked, but because it was there to do and he had the time.
And fence work was the kind of thing that occupied the hands and left the mind alone with itself. On Thursday evening, there was a social at the Grange Hall in Sonoita. Hollister mentioned it at supper in the offhand way of a man who assumes everyone already knows about it. May said she supposed she’d go for an hour.
Wayne said he’d drive them if they wanted. The Grange Hall was the kind of event that mattered in small towns in ways difficult to explain to people who hadn’t grown up in them. Old Carver on the fiddle. Enough food for twice the county. Wayne stood near the back wall with a cup of coffee and tried to be less recognizable than he was, which never worked.
May was at the dessert table talking to a woman about something that made both of them laugh. She was wearing a pale blue dress that was simple and clean and somehow entirely right. Three men asked her to dance in the first 20 minutes. He counted this without meaning to. She accepted the first and declined the next two with a smile that was genuinely warm and left no room for argument.
He danced once with Mrs. Carver, who was an excellent dancer, and who told him directly that he had been watching May Hollister all evening. He said he hadn’t been watching specifically. Mrs. Carver said, “You’ve been watching specifically.” He changed the subject. On the drive back, Hollister sat in the front and May in the back and nobody said much and the Arizona night came through the open windows.
At the ranch, May got out and said good night and went inside. Wayne and Hollister sat on the porch for a while with the last of the evening. Hollister said, after a considerable silence, “She’s a good girl.” Wayne said he knew that. Hollister said, “Her mother was the same way. Easier to see than to say.
” He knocked out his pipe on the porch rail and went inside. Wayne sat there for a while longer. The valley was dark and the stars were very clear and he had the particular feeling of a man who has been trying not to know something and has run out of room to not know it. He rode the fence line again on Friday and on Saturday.
On Saturday, she was at the clothesline again, a larger load this time, working her way methodically through it. He pulled the horse up at the fence and she raised a hand without looking and said, “Good morning.” And he said, “Good morning.” And they had a brief conversation about whether the Henderson place to the north had sold yet, which it had not.
Then, he said it. He had not planned it. He had not rehearsed it. It came out the way true things sometimes do before better judgment could stop them, plainly, without construction, without any of the calculation he had spent the better part of a week applying to the subject.
“You know, May, whoever ends up marrying you is going to be a very lucky man.” He meant it as an honest observation. He expected her to acknowledge it, the way you acknowledge weather. Instead, she went still. Her hand stayed on the shirt. The color came into her face slowly, like a lamp being turned up. She didn’t look at him immediately.
Then she did. Her expression was something he had never seen on her face before. Open and afraid and decided all at once. She looked at him steadily from across the fence line in the August morning sun, with the shirts moving in the wind behind her and the cottonwood making its sound above them both.
And she said very quietly, “I was hoping it would be you.” The valley held them in the particular silence that follows a true thing being said in the open air. He looked at her across the fence. She looked at him. Neither of them moved. He said, “May.” She said, “Yes.” He said, “I meant what I said.
” She said, “I know you did. That’s why I said what I said.” She paused. “I’ve been thinking about you since Monday.” He said, “I’ve been thinking about you since Wednesday 2 years ago.” She was quiet for a moment. Then she said, “You were somewhat slower than I was.” He laughed. He had not expected to laugh. “I’m sorry,” he said.
“Don’t apologize,” she said. “You got there.” He went to Hollister that evening. Hollister was on the porch. Wayne sat down in the other chair and said what he had come to say, plainly and without decoration, the way he had learned from watching Hollister himself, that certain things ought to be said.
He said he wanted to come calling on May with Hollister’s blessing. Hollister was quiet for a moment. The pipe smoke rose in the still evening air. Then he said, “I was beginning to think I’d have to say something directly. May’s been patient. I’ve been patient. The horses have been patient.” Wayne said he was sorry for being slow.
Hollister said, “You’re steady. That’s the same thing, handled better.” He looked at the last of the sun on the east hills. “She doesn’t ask for much,” he said. “But she deserves a man who sees her clearly, who sees what she actually is, not what’s convenient to see.” Wayne said, “I see her.” Hollister looked at him for a long moment. Then he nodded once.
“Supper’s at 6:00 most evenings,” he said. “Ruth sets a good table.” He said it the way a man says a thing that is already settled. He stayed 2 weeks longer than he had planned. Howard Hawks had the Tucson lot booked for the second week in September, and Wayne was there on time. But the 2 weeks before it, he spent in the valley, at suppers, on rides, at the fence line in the mornings.
May came out to the barn once when he was working on a loose section of fence, and handed him the correct tool before he asked for it. He noticed this. She stood there while he finished. He noticed that, too. He fixed the loose gate on the south side of the property without mentioning it. Hollister shook his hand about it 3 days later and said two words.
“Thank you.” Wayne said three. “You’re welcome, Roy.” Before he left for Tucson, he spent an afternoon building a new shelf in the kitchen, on the wall beside the east window. He did not mention he was doing it. He just did it because the old one had been pulling from the wall for 2 weeks, and because the east window got the morning light, and May was always in the kitchen in the mornings.
He came back in October. He asked her at the fence under the cottonwood in the first cold of autumn. He had thought about a more formal setting. The ridge above the valley where you could see the whole San Rafael spread out below. The sun set behind him. But when the moment came, it didn’t feel right to dress it up.
The fence was where they had first said the truth things. It seemed right to come back. He had his mother’s ring in his jacket pocket. A simple silver band with a small stone which she had worn for 32 years and which he had carried since she died in 1942. He said what he meant plainly, the way he had learned she preferred.
He said, “I know I was slow to get here. I know it took me longer than it should have, but I’m here now and I see you clearly and I want to keep seeing you clearly every morning for the rest of my life. I want to build something with you. I would very much like it if you would marry me.” She looked at him for a long moment.
Her eyes were bright. She was smiling in the specific way that has nowhere to hide. She said, “I thought you’d never ask.” He said, “Is that a yes?” She said, “That is absolutely a yes.” He put his mother’s ring on her finger there at the fence under the cottonwood in the October morning. She looked at it for a moment, just a moment, with an expression that was not about the ring, but about the life it stood for.
Then she looked up at him and the cottonwood let go of a few leaves into the October air. And the valley held them the way it always had, quiet and indifferent and faithful. They were married in December in Sonoita in a ceremony that Hollister kept short because he was a man who believed that the important things had already been said before anyone stood up in front of anybody.
May wore a dress her father’s sister had made, simple ivory cotton with small details at the collar. She walked to him with her father on one arm and her face entirely certain. And Wayne thought, “I cannot believe I was slow about this.” That winter he came back between pictures and the winter after that.
The ranch house acquired a new floor in the front room and a second window and the shelf in the kitchen that May used every morning for the better part of 40 years. She never asked about the shelf directly. She just used it. He understood that she was not using the shelf. She was using what the shelf meant.
That he had thought about her mornings before she was there to have them. I have told a great many stories in the course of my work. The ones that stay with me longest are not always the largest. Sometimes they are the ones about a man on a horse at a fence line who had been taking the long way past a clothesline for 10 days and couldn’t quite bring himself to admit why until one August morning the true thing came out before he could think better of it.
He wasn’t a coward. He was careful. Those are not the same thing, but they can look alike for a while. And he had let them look alike for longer than he should have. May knew. She had known since the Wednesday 2 years before the Wednesday that counted. She had been patient in the way of someone who has decided what she wants and is willing to give the other person time to catch up, but not forever.
He got there. The thing you have been looking for is usually right there, doing laundry in the morning sun, waiting for you to stop being so careful and just say the true thing out loud. Don’t wait that long. They don’t make men like John Wayne anymore. Keep riding.
