Posted in

Dean Martin Finally Reveals the Truth About John Wayne, and It Isn’t Good. D

Dean Martin finally reveals the truth about John Wayne [music] and it isn’t good. December 25th, 1995, Dean Martin lay in his Beverly Hills home, his legendary voice reduced to [music] a whisper. The man who had serenated millions, who had made drinking look elegant and loneliness [music] look cool, was taking his final breaths.

But what he [music] confessed to his daughter Dena that Christmas morning would shatter everything America believed about Hollywood’s greatest [music] friendship. For 50 years, the world watched Dean Martin and John Wayne, two titans of American masculinity, brothers in arms, inseparable friends, the smooth kuner and the rugged cowboy.

They represented everything America wanted to believe about [music] loyalty, friendship, and what it meant to be a man in Hollywood’s golden age. But behind the rat pack parties and western film sets, behind the poker games and the bourbon soaked laughter, Dean carried a secret that ated him for decades.

A betrayal so personal, so devastating [music] that he couldn’t speak of it until he was literally hours from death. >> [music] >> What Dean revealed that day wasn’t just about John Wayne. It was about the price of fame, the cost of loyalty, and what happens when your best friend becomes the person you truly hate more than anyone else in the world.

The golden years. [music] But before we understand the hatred, we need to understand the love. Because in 1958, when Dean Martin and John Wayne first met on the set of Rio Bravo, something magical happened. Director Howard Hawks watched in amazement as these two men from completely different worlds clicked instantly.

Deem, the son of an Italian immigrant barber from Stubenville, Ohio, a man who had boxed, dealt cards, and sung his way out of poverty. John, born Marian Morrison in Winteret, Iowa, who had created the most iconic image of American masculinity ever put on film. [music] They shouldn’t have worked as friends.

Dean was smooth, effortless, always making it look [music] easy. John was all hard angles and harder work, building every gesture, [music] every line, every moment of his screen presence through sheer force of will. But somehow on that set in Arizona, they [music] found each other. The poker games started first. Late into the night, after the crew had gone to bed, Dean and John would sit in [music] John’s trailer, cards on the table, bourbon in hand.

Jon nicknamed [music] Dean using the slur with affection, the way men of that era thought they were showing closeness. [music] Dean called him Duke like everyone else, but with a warmth that suggested he’d earned the right. Their families intertwined. [music] Sunday dinners at John’s house in Newport Beach. Dean’s kids playing with John’s kids in the Pacific Surf.

Gene Martin, Dean’s wife, becoming close with Par, John’s third wife. From the outside, it looked like a friendship that would last forever. And Hollywood loved it. [music] The press ate it up. Here were two of the biggest stars in the world, genuinely enjoying each other’s company. [music] No rivalry, no competition, just two men who had made it to the top and were sharing the view.

Weekly dinners at Chason’s restaurant became a ritual. [music] The booth in the back corner always reserved. Dean would arrive first, order a bourbon, [music] light a cigarette, and wait. John would arrive exactly on time because John Wayne was never late. order a scotch and they’d settle in for hours of conversation.

They talked about everything. The state of Hollywood, politics, though they didn’t always agree, their kids, their marriages, their fears about getting older in an industry that worshiped youth. Dean, who rarely opened up to anyone, found himself telling Jon things he’d never told Frank Sinatra.

[music] Never told anyone in the Rat Pack. And John seems to listen, seems to care, seems to be the friend that Dean had never really had. Because Dean [music] Martin, for all his charm and charisma, was fundamentally lonely. The persona he’d built, the drunk who didn’t care about anything, was a wall that kept everyone at a distance.

But with John, or so Dean thought, he could let that wall down. In 1962, they worked together again on The Sons [music] of Katie Elder. The set was even easier than Rio Bravo. They had a shortorthhand now, [music] a rhythm. When Dean forgot his lines, which he often did deliberately to keep things fresh, John would improvise with him, and the results were magic.

Critics [music] praised their chemistry. Audiences couldn’t get enough. America in the 1960s was looking for heroes, for men who represented strength and confidence in an increasingly complicated world. And Dean Martin and John Wayne together [music] seemed to be exactly that. They were selling a dream of male friendship that didn’t exist anymore, if it ever had.

Simple, uncomplicated, loyal. But sources close to both men, people who were there in those private moments, [music] would later reveal that even in those golden years, cracks were forming. Small moments, tiny comments. The way John would correct Dean in front of others, then laugh it off as a [music] joke.

The way Jon always had to be right, always had to have the last word, always had to be the dominant [music] presence in any room. Dean, being Dean, would let it slide. He’d perfected the art of not caring, or at least appearing not to care. But his closest friends, people like Sammy Davis Jr. and Joey Bishop, noticed something.

They saw the flash in Dean’s eyes when John [music] would make a particular type of comment. They saw how Dean’s jaw would tighten just for a second before [music] the easy smile returned. And those cracks, those tiny fissurers in what looked like perfect friendship, they started with something John said to Dean’s son in 1964.

Words that [music] Dean’s son, Dino, would remember for the rest of his life. Words that would mark the beginning of the end. Because what John Wayne said to 15year-old Dean Paul Martin wasn’t just an opinion. It was a judgment. [music] And it cut deeper than anyone realized. The first betrayal.

Dean Paul Martin, known as Dino to everyone who loved him, was 15 years old in 1964. [music] A good kid by all accounts, polite, respectful, trying to figure out who he was in the shadow of one of the most famous fathers in the world. He loved aviation, loved planes, would spend hours at the Santa Monica airport watching the aircraft take off and land, dreaming of becoming a pilot.

It was pure, [music] this passion, uncomplicated by Hollywood, by fame, by any of the things that made Dean’s [music] life so complicated. One afternoon at one of those Sunday gatherings at John Wayne’s Newport Beach [music] House, Dino found himself alone with Duke on the deck, watching the sunset over the Pacific.

And [music] Dino, excited, nervous, wanting approval from this man his father admired so [music] much, started talking about his dreams of flying. John Wayne listened, nodded, and then he said something [music] that Dino would later tell his mother changed everything. Flying’s fine, kid, but you know what real men do? They fight.

They don’t sing and [music] dance like your old man. They face things head on. Your father, he’s soft, made a career out of being soft. You don’t want to end up like that. Dino didn’t know what to say. He [music] was 15. John Wayne was well, John Wayne. So, he nodded, mumbled something, and went inside, confused, [music] hurt, feeling like he’d been told his father was somehow less than.

He didn’t tell Dean immediately. didn’t know how, but he told his mother, Jean. And Jean, who had spent years watching John Wayne operate, [music] who had seen the subtle ways he diminished Dean in social settings, she was furious. She confronted Dean that night, told him what Jon had said to their son, and for one of the rare times in their marriage, Jean saw her husband truly angry.

Not the flash temper he’d show and then forget. Not the irritation he’d drown in bourbon. Real deep burning anger. “He called me soft,” Dean asked. His [music] voice quiet in a way that scared Jeanie more than if he’d been shouting. He told our 15-year-old son that his father wasn’t a real man.

[music] Jeanie said, “And Dean, you need to do something about this. [music] You need to tell John this isn’t okay. Dean planned [music] to. He really did. He was going to confront Jon at a party the following week at Frank’s place in Palm Springs. He prepared what he’d say, rehearsed it even, which wasn’t like Dean at all.

But when the night came and Dean walked into Frank’s compound, ready for the confrontation, John Wayne was already there standing at the bar holding a scotch. And when he saw Dean, his [music] face lit up in that John Wayne smile that had charmed millions. John called [music] out, crossing the room.

And he was holding flowers, white roses, which he handed to Dean with a laugh. For Jeanie, John said, “Heard she’s been under the weather.” Jeanie hadn’t been under the weather. It was a lie [music] or a misunderstanding or something. But the gesture, the public gesture of friendship, of thoughtfulness, it disarmed [music] Dean completely because this was John Wayne’s gift, [music] though Dean didn’t fully understand it yet.

John knew how to perform [music] friendship, knew how to make the public gesture that made it impossible to have the private confrontation. How do you accuse someone of betrayal when they’re handing you flowers [music] and smiling? So Dean smiled back, took the flowers, made a joke about John trying to steal his wife, and the moment passed.

The confrontation never happened. Dean swallowed the hurt, ordered a [music] bourbon, and played his role. But something changed in Dean that night. Friends who were there, Sammy Davis Jr. in particular, [music] noticed it. Dean started drinking more faster. The easy looseness that usually characterized his drinking took on a harder edge.

He was numbing something. Over the next 3 years, Dean began keeping score. Every time Jon would make a comment about real men versus entertainers. Every time Jon would hold court at a party, positioning himself as the authority on everything from politics to parenting, Dean would file it away.

Joey Bishop later said that Dean started referring to John as the [music] expert in private conversations, always with a bitter edge. “Better ask the expert,” Dean would say when someone brought up John’s name. “The expert on being a real man.” [music] The public friendship continued. They’d still have dinners at Chasons, though less frequently.

They’d still smile for the cameras. Hollywood columnists [music] still wrote about the great friendship between the Kuner and the cowboy. [music] But Dean’s inner circle knew. They saw how Dean’s eyes would harden when J’s name came up, how he’d change the subject, how he started avoiding events if he knew Jon would be there.

And then in 1967, John Wayne did something unforgivable. [music] Something that crossed a line that even Dean’s peopleleasing nature couldn’t smooth over. Something [music] involving Dean’s son that Dean would never ever forgive. What happened next wasn’t [music] just a betrayal of friendship.

It was a calculated act that put Dean’s family in the national spotlight for all the wrong reasons. And John [music] Wayne didn’t just fail to help, he made it worse. The unforgivable [music] act, 1967. Dean Paul Martin, now 18, was caught at [music] a party in Beverly Hills with marijuana. In today’s world, it would barely register.

But in 1967, in conservative Hollywood [music] for the son of Dean Martin, it was a scandal waiting to explode. Dean got the call at 3:00 in the morning. [music] His son in custody. The press didn’t know yet, but they would. They always did. And Dean, panicked in a way his friends had never seen him, started making calls.

This is what you did in Hollywood when your family was in trouble. You called [music] in favors. You talked to people. You managed the story before it could manage you. And Dean’s first call after his lawyer was to John Wayne. Because despite everything, despite the comments and the slights and the growing resentment, Dean still thought of John as someone he could count on, someone who would understand that this was about protecting a kid who’d made a stupid [music] mistake.

The call went to John’s house in Newport Beach. John answered, [music] his voice alert despite the early hour. And Dean explained the situation. His son, the marijuana, the police, the press that would descend in hours. He needed help containing this. Needed Jon’s connections, his influence, [music] his friendship. There was a pause on the line, a long pause.

And then John Wayne said something that Dean would replay in his mind for the rest of his life. Dean, kid needs to learn the hard way. This is what happens when fathers are too permissive. Can’t protect them from everything. Dean couldn’t believe what he was hearing. John, this is my son. This could ruin his life. Ruin his life.

John’s voice took on that [music] lecturing tone, that expert tone. Character is built through consequences, Dean. You’ve sheltered [music] these kids too much. Hollywood spoils them. This might be the best thing that [music] could happen to him. And then John did something that went beyond refusing to help.

[music] Something that Dean’s friends would later call evil. Though Dean himself [music] would never use that word. John Wayne called Hetta Hopper. Heta Hopper the most powerful gossip columnist [music] in Hollywood. The woman who could make or break careers with a single column. and John gave her a quote anonymously at first, though everyone would know it was him.

Some Hollywood fathers are too [music] permissive with their children. They forget that being a parent means setting boundaries, teaching consequences. When you’re too busy being a friend to your kids, you fail them as a father. The story exploded, not just in Heta’s column, but everywhere. Dean [music] Paul Martin’s arrest became national news and woven through every article was this suggestion, [music] this implication that Dean himself was to blame, too permissive, too focused [music] on his career, not enough of a father. Dean Paul was humiliated. The charges were eventually reduced. [music] The incident mostly forgotten by the public within months. But the damage to the relationship between father and son was deeper. Dino felt he’d embarrassed his father. Dean [music] felt he’d failed to protect his son. And both of them knew

that John Wayne had made it worse. Gene Martin, according to multiple witnesses, confronted John at a party 2 weeks later, screamed at him, actually screamed, which shocked everyone present because Jean was usually so composed. You betrayed us,” she [music] said, her voice shaking.

“When we needed you, you made it worse. What kind of friend does that?” John, according to those same witnesses, [music] didn’t apologize. Instead, he doubled down. “I told the truth,” he said. “Sometimes friends have to tell hard truths.” Frank Sinatra had to physically step between them. Had to escort Jean out of the room before things got worse.

And later that night, Frank went to Dean’s house, found him in the den, surrounded by empty bourbon bottles, crying. Frank had never seen Dean cry. Not when his first marriage fell apart. Not when his career had rough patches. Never. But that night, Dean was broken. He went after my kid, Frank. Dean said. My kid.

And he did it [music] on purpose. He wanted to hurt me through my son. Why? Frank asked. Why would [music] Duke do that? Dean looked at Frank with red rimmed eyes. Because [music] he doesn’t see me as an equal. He never did. To him, I’m the entertainer, the soft one, the one who doesn’t measure up.

And he wanted to remind me of that. He wanted to remind me of my place. Frank tried to mediate, tried to get the two men in a room together, but Dean refused. For 6 months, Dean [music] wouldn’t take Jon’s calls, wouldn’t be in the same room with him. The friendship, at least [music] in private, was over.

But Hollywood is a small town. And eventually, [music] circumstances forced them back together. A charity event they both committed to, a tribute to Howard Hawks, where they both had to speak. Industry [music] events where avoiding each other would create more scandal than their actual feud. So they performed. Dean smiled.

John smiled. They shook hands for cameras. They gave quotes to columnists about [music] their unbreakable bond. And the public, the friendship [snorts] looked intact. But everyone close to them [music] knew the truth. Sammy Davis Jr. later said, “After what happened with Dino, Dean never trusted [music] Duke again.

He’d be in the same room with him, but the warmth was gone. It was all performance. And Dean’s performance was flawless because Dean Martin was above all else a professional. He could perform Friendship with the same skill he performed drunkenness on stage. No one watching would know it was fake. Except Dean knew and John knew.

[music] And in the knowing, something poisonous began to grow. Not the clean break of an ended friendship, but the slow rot of a friendship that had to continue for appearanc’s [music] sake. And that rot would fester for another 28 years. Over the next two decades, Dean and John were trapped in a friendship that had [music] become a prison.

And the moments that seemed like reconciliation to the public were actually the most toxic [music] encounters of all. The Cold War years. The 1970s were a strange time for both men. Dean’s career was shifting. The Rat Pack era was over. His television variety show was winding down. He was drinking more, performing less, slowly withdrawing from the Hollywood social [music] scene.

John Wayne was having his own reckoning. Cancer in 1964 [music] had nearly killed him. He’d beaten it, but it changed him. Made him more rigid, more convinced of his own righteousness, more [music] determined to control his public image. They’d see each other at industry events, always cordial, [music] always performing.

But beneath the surface, the resentment was calcifying into something harder. The 1972 [music] Academy Awards. John Wayne was presenting. Dean was in the audience, nominated [music] for his work in a film that hadn’t done well, but that he was privately proud of. He didn’t win, but that wasn’t what made the night memorable.

John Wayne took the stage, [music] looked out at the audience, and in his acceptance speech for a different award, thanked his real friends in Hollywood. The emphasis on real was subtle, but everyone who knew the history caught it. The camera [music] cut to Dean’s face. For just a fraction of a second before he caught himself, Dean’s expression was pure ice. Then the smile returned.

The applause continued and the moment passed. But backstage, Dean found Joey Bishop and said, “I’m glad he knows the difference between real friends and whatever we are.” The Polo Lounge incident in 1975 became legendary among those who witnessed it. Both men happened to be at the Beverly Hills Hotel the same afternoon.

Dean was having lunch. John was at the bar [music] and somehow inevitably they ended up in conversation. [music] It started with politics. Vietnam. John was defending the war, defending American intervention, doing his usual John Wayne routine about strength and resolve. Dean, who rarely talked politics publicly, had lost his patience.

You talk about strength, Dean said, his voice [music] quiet but carrying. But you’ve never actually fought in a war, Duke. None of us have. We just played soldiers in movies. The room went silent. People at nearby tables stopped eating. John’s face darkened. I served my country in my own way. By making propaganda films, Dean asked.

By lecturing everyone about honor while being safe in [music] Hollywood. At least I stand for something. John shot back. At least I [music] don’t just stumble around drunk pretending not to care about anything. And Dean [music] smiled. that dangerous smile he’d perfected over decades. At least I don’t lecture people [music] while being a fraud.

They were inches apart. John’s hands were clenched into fists. Dean was swaying slightly, [music] whether from bourbon or adrenaline. No one could tell. Hotel security was moving toward them when Jack Nicholson [music] of all people stepped between them. “Gentlemen,” Jack said, his voice soothing.

Let’s not do [music] this here. They separated. John left through one exit. Dean through another. But everyone who was there knew they’d witnessed [music] something. The myth of the great friendship had cracked wide open. At least for those 30 seconds. 1978 brought another wound. Dean Paul Martin, now 29, enlisted in the Air National Guard.

He’d become a skilled pilot despite [music] or perhaps because of everything that had happened in his youth. It was his passion, his identity, separate from his famous father. When the news broke, John Wayne gave a quote to the press. Finally, a real Martin is emerging. Good to see the boy found his backbone. The implication was clear that Dean Paul had needed to escape his father’s influence to become a real man.

that military service was somehow redemption for being Dean Martin’s son. Dean read the quote in the Los Angeles Times over breakfast. Gan sitting across from him watched [music] his face. He even tries to own my children. Dean said quietly. [music] He can’t just let Dino have this. He has to make it about me, about my failures.

You should say something, Jean urged publicly. tell people what he’s really like. But Dean shook his head. What’s the point? America loves John Wayne. They’d never [music] believe me. And frankly, I’m too tired to fight anymore. And that was the tragedy of the later years. Dean was tired. Tired of performing friendship.

Tired of swallowing his pride. Tired of [music] pretending. The drinking that had once been part of his act became medicine against the exhaustion of it all. By the late 70s, they barely spoke. When they had to be in the same room, they’d nod, [music] exchange pleasantries, and move on.

The friendship was dead in all but name. And then in May of 1979, Dean got a call. John Wayne [music] was dying. Cancer again, but this time it was winning. and John [music] wanted to see him. Dean didn’t want to go. Told Frank he couldn’t. Told Sammy he wouldn’t. But they convinced him. Told him he’d regret it if he didn’t.

Told him it was the right thing to [music] do. So Dean went to UCLA Medical Center, walked into John Wayne’s private [music] room, and had their final conversation. A conversation [music] that would haunt him for the rest of his life. What happened in that hospital room wasn’t the reconciliation Dean hoped for. It was one final reminder of exactly who John Wayne really was.

And what John asked Dean to do at his funeral was the ultimate [music] betrayal. The final confrontation. May 1979. John Wayne’s hospital room [music] was filled with flowers, telegrams, messages from presidents and movie stars and fans around the world. But when Dean Martin walked in, John asked everyone [music] else to leave. They were alone.

The cowboy and the kuner, two old men in their 70s now, facing mortality. John looked [music] terrible. The cancer had taken so much of him, but his eyes were still sharp, still calculating. [music] Still, John Wayne. “Thanks for coming,” John said, his voice weak but clear.

Dean nodded, sat in the chair beside the bed, said [music] nothing. “Listen,” John continued. “I know we’ve had our disagreements over the years. [music] Things got said, feelings got hurt, but that’s what happens with real friendships, right? You fight, you make up, you move on. Dean stared at him. Disagreements. [music] That’s what John was calling it.

Disagreements. I’m sorry, John said. For whatever I did that upset you. For any misunderstandings. Misunderstandings. Dean wanted to laugh, wanted to scream, but he just sat there waiting. I need to ask you something, John said. And now his voice took on that tone, that asking for a favor tone that Dean had [music] heard so many times.

When I’m gone, and it’s going to [music] be soon, I need you to speak at my funeral. Dean felt [music] something cold settle in his chest. The world needs to see us together one last time, John continued. Needs to know that the friendship [music] was real. That despite everything, we were brothers. You understand what I’m asking? Dean understood perfectly.

John [music] Wayne, even dying, was managing his public image, was making [music] sure the story would be told the way he wanted it told. And he needed Dean to play [music] his part one last time. Give them the Dean Martin they expect, John said. The charming one, the one who loved his friend Duke. Make me look [music] good, And there it was, the final ask, the final performance of friendship that [music] John needed from Dean.

Not for Dean’s sake, not for their friendship’s sake, for John Wayne’s legacy. Dean could have said no. could have told Jon the truth. Could have walked out of that hospital room and let Jon face death without this final manipulation. But he didn’t. Maybe it was Catholic guilt. Maybe it was Hollywood conditioning.

Maybe it was just exhaustion. But Dean nodded. “I’ll do it,” he said. John Wayne smiled. “I knew I could count on you.” Dean left the hospital and went straight to a bar. drank until Frank found him, concerned because Dean had been gone for hours. “How [music] was it?” Frank asked. He apologized for misunderstandings, [music] Dean said the word bitter in his mouth.

“30 years of betrayal, and he called it misunderstandings.” [music] “And then he asked me to make him look good at his funeral.” “And you said yes,” Frank said, [music] not a question. I said, “Yes,” Dean confirmed. “I’m going to stand up there and tell everyone what a great friend he was. What a great man. I’m going to lie for him one last time.

” John Wayne died on June 11th, 1979. The funeral was a state event. Everyone who was anyone in Hollywood was there, [music] and Dean Martin delivered a eulogy that had people in tears. He talked about Jon’s loyalty, [music] his strength, his friendship. He told funny stories about the poker [music] games, the dinners at Chason’s, the easy camaraderie of two men who understood each other perfectly.

He made John Wayne sound like the greatest friend anyone could ever have. And according to everyone who knew Dean well, it was the [music] greatest performance of his career because not a single word of the warmth he conveyed was real. After the funeral, Sammy found Dean in his car, [music] hands shaking.

“I just buried a stranger,” Dean said. “I stood up [music] there and praised a man I truly hated. And I did it so well that people believed every word.” “Then why did you do it?” Sammy [music] asked. Dean looked at him with empty eyes. “Because that’s what [music] we do in Hollywood. We perform even when it kills us.

” But Dean’s real confession, the truth he could never tell publicly, would wait another 16 years until Christmas Day, 1995, when he was finally free to tell the whole truth. The truth revealed December 25th, 1995. We return to where we began. Dean Martin, [music] 78 years old, dying of emphyma and kidney failure.

his daughter Dena at his bedside. Between doses of morphine, clarity would come in waves. And in one of those waves, Dean wanted to talk about [music] Duke. “Your brother,” Dean said, his voice barely a whisper. “Your brother died trying [music] to prove he was man enough for John Wayne’s approval.” “Dean Paul Martin had died in a plane crash in 1987. Air National Guard pilot.

Exactly what John Wayne had praised him for becoming. And Dean had carried the weight of that for eight years. And I spent 50 years, Dean [music] continued, doing the same thing, trying to prove I was man enough, trying to measure up to John’s idea of what a man should be. We both failed, baby.

We both failed because John never saw anyone as enough. Dena held her father’s hand, crying, listening. “The person I truly hated,” [music] Dean said. And now tears were running down his own face. “The person I truly hated wasn’t [music] John Wayne. It was myself. for needing his approval, for swallowing [music] my pride, for delivering that eulogy, for letting him define what it meant to be a man when everything I’d built my career on was rejecting [music] that exact definition.

This was the revelation, the twist that changed everything. Because Dean Martin’s [music] whole persona, the smooth, effortless, perpetually drunk character he’d created, [music] was a rejection of John Wayne’s brand of masculinity. Dean made [music] not caring look cool. Made vulnerability in his own way acceptable.

But in his private [music] life, in his friendship with John, Dean had betrayed his own values, [music] had sought approval from the exact kind of rigid masculinity he spent his career undermining. “I forgive him,” Dean said, [music] his breathing labored now. I forgive John, but I’ll never forgive myself for not walking away sooner, for not protecting Dino better, [music] for caring what John Wayne thought of me when I should have known better.

Those were among Dean Martin’s last coherent words. He died later that day on Christmas 1995, surrounded by family. And the secret he’d carried for so long, the hatred he’d nursed for decades, died with him. Except for this confession, [music] this one moment of truth that his daughter Dena later shared with the world.

Closing. [music] This story isn’t really about Dean Martin and John Wayne. It’s about what happens when we sacrifice our authentic selves for someone else’s approval. When we let toxic people define our worth because they have power, fame, or cultural authority. Dean Martin spent his career teaching America that it was okay to not take things too seriously, to be vulnerable, charming, [music] human.

But in his private life, he forgot his own lesson. The real tragedy. By the time he remembered, by the time he understood that John Wayne’s approval was never worth having, [music] it was too late. His son was gone. His friendship was a performance. And all that remained was regret.