The International Hotel backstage after a show had its own specific atmosphere, part machinery, part aftermath, the organized confusion of a production winding down while still carrying the residue of what had just happened on the other side of the wall. Equipment moved on carts, people moved with purposes, the air held the heat of the performance and the cold of the air conditioning in uneven layers, and the sound of the casino floor came through the building’s bones as a constant low frequency beneath everything else. Elvis had just finished his second show of the evening. He was in the corridor outside his dressing room, still in the white suit, still carrying the energy of 2 hours on stage in the specific way that performers carry it after. Not depleted, not exactly, but different. The body’s systems running at a register that takes time to come down from. Joe Esposito was beside him. Two
security men were nearby. A small constellation of people who existed in the orbit of an Elvis Presley post show occupied the space with the practiced ease of people who have done this many times. Diahann Carroll had come through the backstage entrance at 9:40. She was there that week performing her own engagement at another hotel on the strip.
Two Las Vegas careers running parallel in the August heat. Someone had arranged the pass. She had not asked for it, but she had accepted it because she had been thinking for some time about what she wanted to say and had decided that thinking was finished and the saying needed to happen. She moved through the backstage with the particular quality she brought to every room she entered, unhurried, precise, the specific authority of a woman who has spent years being the first and sometimes the only in rooms that were not built with her in mind and has developed from that experience a posture that requires nothing from the room in order to be fully itself. She found Elvis in the corridor. He saw her coming. There are people who, when they enter a space, change the quality of the space, not through volume or performance, but through the specific force of their presence, the accumulated weight of who they are and what they have done and
what they are prepared to do next. Diahann Carroll was one of those people. She had been the first black woman to star in a non-servant role in a network television drama. She had walked through doors in American entertainment that required more than talent to open, that required the specific willingness to be the one who opened them, to absorb everything that came with being first, to continue through.
She was 33 years old and had been absorbing what that cost since she was 17, and the cost had not diminished her. If anything, it had clarified her, the way certain pressures clarify rather than crush. She moved through backstage corridors the way she moved through everything, with the full commitment of someone who has never been able to afford the luxury of ambivalence.
She was not someone he knew well. They had been in the same industry for the same years, had moved through the same general landscape of American entertainment in the 1960s without their paths crossing with any frequency. He knew who she was. He knew what she had done, the television work, the stage work, the specific significance of what she represented in the industry, the doors she had opened by walking through them.
He had the respect for her that a professional has for another professional who has done real work against real resistance. He also knew, from the quality of her approach, that she had not come to congratulate him on the show. She stopped in front of him. The people around Elvis did what people around Elvis did when a situation presented itself that was not a threat, but was clearly not casual.
They adjusted, created space, remained present without being proximate. Joe took a half step back. The security men found other directions to look. The corridor continued its operations around a 10-ft radius of suddenly private space. “Mr. Presley,” Diane said. “Ms. Carroll,” Elvis said. She looked at him for a moment with the direct assessing quality that was simply how she looked at things.
Not unkindly, not warmly, just clearly. “I want to say something to you, and I want you to hear it the way I mean it, which is directly and without malice. All right,” he said. She held his gaze. “You became the heir to a temple that was built by other people’s pain. The music that made you, the gospel, the blues, the rhythm and blues, that music was built in churches and juke joints and Saturday nights that black people in this country created because they needed somewhere to put what they were carrying.
That music was built out of a specific American experience that was not yours.” She paused. “And you took it. You walked through doors that opened for you in ways they did not open for the people who built what was behind them. You sold what they created to an audience that would not buy it from them.
” Another pause. “You took something that wasn’t yours.” The corridor held the words. Not the way words are held when they land and disperse, the way words are held when they land and stay, when they have found the specific gravity of a thing that is true and that the room recognizes as true and that no available response can simply neutralize.
The people at the edges of the space could not hear what had been said. They could see from the quality of the stillness that something had landed. Joe Esposito, who had been with Elvis long enough to read any room Elvis was in, saw the stillness on Elvis’s face and understood that the correct move was no move at all.
Elvis looked at her. Not defensively, not with the reflexive posture of someone who has been accused of something and is preparing a counter. He looked at her the way he had listened to things in a garage on a Tuesday night. The way he had listened in a church on a Wednesday morning. With the quality of someone who has decided that what is being said deserves to be fully received before anything else happens.
He was quiet for a long time. Long enough that the people at the edges of the space who could see the conversation without hearing it understood from the quality of the stillness that something significant was occurring in that corridor. Long enough for the words to do what they were going to do. Long enough for Elvis to feel the full weight of them before he attempted anything in response.
Advertisements
“You’re right.” Elvis said. Not as a concession, not as a strategic retreat, as a statement. “That music built me.” He said. “I grew up in Tupelo, Mississippi in two rooms with no running water. And what came through the radio and through the walls of the churches in my neighborhood, black gospel, black rhythm and blues, the sound of people expressing something that I didn’t have words for but that I needed. That sound was my education.
It was the only education that mattered to me.” He paused. “I didn’t take it the way a thief takes something. I was a kid who was drowning and that music was the only thing I could hold on to. Diane was watching him. But I know what you’re saying, Elvis continued. I know what opened for me that didn’t open for the people who created what I was carrying.
I know that Little Richard was playing the same music I was playing, and the doors didn’t open the same way. I know that the radio stations that wouldn’t play his records played mine. I know what that means. He looked at her directly. I’ve known it for a long time. Knowing it is not the same as it being right.
The casino floor hummed through the building’s walls. “Then what do you do with that knowledge?” Diane said. Her tone had shifted slightly, not softened exactly, but changed in quality. The question was genuine. Elvis thought about this. “I’m not sure there’s enough I can do with it,” he said. “I can’t give back what the industry took.
I can’t fix what was wrong with the doors that opened and the ones that didn’t.” He paused. “What I can do is make sure that when people watch me on that stage, they know where the music came from. I can make sure the people who taught me what I know are standing beside me, not behind me.” He looked at her. “That’s not enough.
I know it’s not enough, but it’s what I can do.” Diane looked at him. This was not what she had expected. She had expected, she was honest enough with herself to know what she had expected, some version of the available defenses. The denial that his music owed what it owed. The redirect toward his own poverty, his own struggle.
The argument that he too had started from nothing, and that starting from nothing was its own kind of qualification. The insistence that music belongs to everyone, that art cannot be owned, that borders drawn around human expression are themselves a kind of injustice. She had heard all of these before from other people in other rooms, delivered with varying degrees of sincerity, and she had come prepared for them.
She had also, somewhere underneath the preparation, been prepared for the more sophisticated version. The man who acknowledged everything she said, agreed with all of it, and remained entirely unchanged by the acknowledgement. The performance of understanding as a substitute for its substance. She had not come prepared for this.
For someone who had heard the accusation and not tried to escape it, but had simply stood in it and agreed, and then said something true about what he knew and what he could do with the knowing. For the quality of weight in how he carried it, not performed weight, not the visible labor of someone demonstrating their discomfort for an audience, but the actual weight of a person who has thought about a difficult thing for a long time and has not been able to make it lighter.
The corridor was quiet between them. Not the silence of a conversation that has run out of things to say, the silence of a conversation that has arrived somewhere and is taking stock of where it has arrived. “You understand that acknowledgement without action is just a more comfortable version of ignorance,” she said.
“Yes,” Elvis said. “And?” “And I’m trying to do better than acknowledgement.” He held her gaze. “Whether I succeed at that is something you’d have to judge from the outside. I can’t be the one to tell you that.” She looked at him for a long moment. The man in front of her was not the man she had built in her mind on the walk from the backstage entrance to this corridor.
The easy target, the beneficiary of the system who would perform discomfort and offer nothing underneath it. This man was something more complicated. A person who had been given something extraordinary by a system that had given it to him at someone else’s expense and who knew it and who carried that knowledge with what appeared to be genuine weight rather than the performance of weight.
Whether that was enough was a separate question. Whether anything was enough was a question that did not resolve in corridors or in single conversations or perhaps at all. But it was something. Diahann walked toward the exit at the far end of the corridor. She stopped. She turned. Elvis was still where she had left him watching her with the same quality of attention he had given her throughout the conversation.
Complete, genuine, not looking away. “Every time you sing that music, remember the faces of the people who built it. Remember the churches they built it in. Remember what they were carrying when they built it.” She paused. “Because they haven’t forgotten where it went.” She walked through the door. The assistant who later told the story was a young woman named Patricia Hughes, 24 years old in August of 1969, working her third month in the backstage operations of the International Hotel.
She had been carrying a rack of garments from the costume area when Diahann Carroll had walked past her in the other direction. A woman moving with such clear purpose that Patricia had stepped aside without thinking. The instinctive accommodation of someone who recognizes when a person is going somewhere that matters.
She had continued down the corridor, had found her route taking her past the cluster of people at its edge and had stopped there because stopping was the natural thing to do when a rack needed repositioning and the space ahead was occupied. She had repositioned the rack. She had found no particular urgency to move on.
She had heard most of the conversation. She had heard enough. There are moments that you understand while they are happening to be outside the ordinary register of events. Moments that have a different weight, a different texture, that communicate to something in you below the level of analysis that what you are witnessing is not the usual thing.
Patricia Hughes had been in Las Vegas long enough to have watched famous people navigate the specific pressures of that city, and she had developed the professional understanding that what happened backstage was not hers to carry outward. She had witnessed things and kept them. This was different from the other things she had kept.
It was different in the way that made the keeping feel less like discretion and more like the protection of something that was not hers to expose. Something that had happened between two people who were being fully themselves, that had the quality of a private reckoning conducted in a semi-public space, and deserving of the privacy it had not technically been granted.
She did not tell anyone about it immediately. Not that night, not that week, not that year. She carried it the way certain things are carried. Not as a secret exactly, but as something that was too interior to be made into ordinary conversation, that belonged to the space between what you witness and what you narrate.
She told it for the first time in 1985 to her daughter, who was studying American cultural history and had asked her mother whether she had anything relevant from her years in Las Vegas. Patricia had thought about this for a moment. Then she had told her daughter about a corridor in August of 1969 and a conversation she had not been meant to hear, and two people who had said true things to each other in the specific way that true things can be said without comfort, without resolution, but with the kind of honesty that at least does not pretend the problem is smaller than it is. “Who won?” her daughter had asked. Patricia had looked at her. “That’s not what it was,” she said. Elvis carried the Sweet Inspirations on his stage for the rest of his performing life. He did not often speak publicly about why, in the specific way that people who have the need to explain it, but those who worked with him in those
years noted that his relationship with the black musicians and vocalists in his ensemble was not the relationship of a headliner to his supporting cast. It was something different, more attentive, more considered with a quality of deliberate acknowledgement in it that was not required by the situation and was therefore meaningful precisely because it was not required.
Whether this was sufficient was a question that did not have an answer that fit inside a single answer. Whether the corridor in the conversation was responsible for it or whether the corridor simply confirmed something that was already present was a question that Patricia Hughes, in her various tellings of the story across the years, did not attempt to resolve.
What she said when she told it was that she had watched two people stand in the same difficult truth from opposite sides and not flinch from it. That was what she had seen. That was what she carried.
