Posted in

Why Queen Mary Actually Hated Her Son Edward VIII 

 

 

 

Some letters are never  framed. In July 1938, a 71-year-old widow living in Marlborough House wrote to her  firstborn, a man who, just 18 months prior, had been the king-emperor of the largest empire in history, but was now living in France with a woman she utterly refused to accept  or forgive.

One sentence from that letter explains her  entire life. I have always put my country before everything else. This is not a story about  love. It is the tragedy of a mother who chose the crown over a son who had undermined the monarchy. For the next 17 years,    she treated her own child like a polite stranger.

To understand this woman, one must know her youth. Mary of Teck was born in 1867  at Kensington Palace. On paper, her family sounded grand, but they were minor German aristocracy with a chronic lack of money. Her father, the Duke of Teck, came from a morganatic, meaning lower status, branch of the Royal  House of Württemberg.

 Her mother, Princess Mary Adelaide, was a granddaughter of King George  III and weighed around 250 lb, a fact the press of the day discussed without  any tact. The family was so broke that in the 1880s, they had to flee the country to escape  creditors. They lived frugally in Florence, and upon their return, tried to marry Mary,  known as May at home, off as quickly as possible to anyone respectable.

The young princess was neither a  beauty nor a flirt. She spent hours reading books, visiting museums, and memorizing royal genealogies. High collars and tightly bound hair became her uniform. By the age of 16, she had learned a crucial lesson. Her only currency in this world was absolute correctness in every detail of her behavior.

  In 1891, she was betrothed to Prince  Albert Victor, the eldest son of the Prince of Wales and second in line to the throne, known to the family as Eddie. Six weeks after the engagement, Eddie died of influenza during  a European pandemic. The question of what to do with the betrothed bride hung awkwardly over the royal house for nearly  a year.

A pragmatic solution was found. She was married off to the next brother in line. In July 1893,    she married Prince George, Duke of York. The marriage proved successful. George was a harsh, disciplined man obsessed with stamp collecting and naval punctuality, possessing the typical emotional detachment of the English upper class.

He suited Mary perfectly. They wrote letters to each other even when they were in the same house,  and they had six children. Their union lacked emotional warmth.    It was a flawless execution of duty with the precision of a Swiss railway. Private emotions were never allowed to interfere with the public status of the  crown.

 When George became king in 1910, Mary fully transformed into the platonic ideal of a queen consort. An upright  posture, a constant tiara, incredible patience for ceremony, and a wardrobe forever  frozen in the styles of 1912 to provide an illusion of stability. She did not embrace modernity, rarely smiled in photographs, and always walked two steps  behind her husband.

Over all those years, she never complained. Yet, this very woman would later learn that her eldest son was ready to throw away everything she lived for. Mary’s eldest son, known to the family as David, grew up as an emotionally starved rebel in the strict atmosphere of his father’s dictates. He became a favorite of the press and the planet’s top media  star.

Yet, his passion for alcohol and married women drove his father to openly pray that the throne would pass  to his younger brother, Bertie. In January 1931, the Prince’s life. They met during a weekend country getaway at Burrough Court. The American woman had a complicated  past. She was already divorced from her first husband, a military pilot, and was currently married to a shipping broker, Ernest Simpson.

Advertisements

Wallis was not a conventional beauty, but she possessed an incredible  charm and knew how to capture a man’s attention. David fell  instantly in love. By 1934, she had displaced his former mistress,  and by the following year, the Prince was showering her with expensive jewelry and ignoring  his state duties.

The British press abstained from publishing anything about the romance due to  a gentleman’s agreement. But European and American newspapers actively printed photos of the couple on holiday in the Mediterranean. These papers landed on Queen Mary’s breakfast  table every day, but she privately and publicly ignored Mrs.

Simpson’s existence. On January 20th, 1936, George V  died after a long illness. It was later revealed that his physician,  Lord Dawson, had accelerated the monarch’s death with a lethal dose of so that the news would make the morning edition of the prestigious Times  rather than the vulgar evening papers.

David ascended the throne as Edward VIII at the age of 41, becoming the first modern king whose private life was thrust into the crosshairs of global media.  His reign lasted only 10 months and horrified the British political establishment. The new monarch had no intention  of hiding his relationship.

 And in the summer of 1936, he went on an Adriatic cruise with  Wallace. In October of that year, Simpson filed for divorce. The court granted the decree, but under English law, it would not become absolute for  6 months. This meant that throughout the ensuing political crisis, Wallace was legally not yet a free woman.

  On November 16th, 1936, Prime Minister Stanley Baldwin officially  informed the king that the church, Parliament, and the dominion governments would never accept Wallace  Simpson as queen. Edward was faced with three choices. Give up his lover, pursue a morganatic marriage,  which the cabinet immediately rejected, or abdicate the throne.

The king chose the latter. Queen Mary learned the full extent of this decision during difficult meetings at Marlborough House late that year. She had hoped her son  would show discipline and place his duty to the dynasty and empire above his personal feelings. The news of the abdication shocked her. She tried to reason with David, reminding him that the throne would now fall upon  his painfully shy and stammering brother Bertie, who was completely unprepared for the role.

She pointed out the damage to the monarchy, which just 19  years earlier, during the war, had been rebranded from a German dynasty into the British House of Windsor. But David was immovable. Queen Mary could understand a monarch with a secret mistress,  but she could not comprehend a king who would abandon the crown just to marry her.

On December 10th,  1936, Edward signs the instrument of abdication  in the presence of his three brothers. The following evening, he addressed  the nation by radio, declaring that he could not carry the heavy burden of sovereignty without the support of the woman he loved. Queen Mary listened to the broadcast  and said only, “This is a dreadful moment for us.

” She emphasized the word us, meaning the institution and the family, not David himself.  The next morning, Bertie became King George the VI. His wife, Elizabeth, loathed the situation and harbored a lifelong resentment toward Wallis. The two queens, the widow and the new king’s wife, united around one unyielding principle.

Mrs. Simpson would never be allowed anywhere near the British throne again. The conflict surrounding the abdication did not end in December 1936.  A protracted legal and political war lay ahead. The main bone of contention was the style of her royal highness,  which Wallis Simpson expected to receive after the wedding as the wife of a royal prince.

The new king,  George the VI, the government, and the royal household stood firmly against it. On May 27th, 1937,  less than 2 weeks before Edward’s scheduled wedding in France, an official decree was issued. The letters patent  stated that the Duke of Windsor retained the title of royal highness for himself alone, and that his wife and any future descendants would not share it.

This decision was completely unprecedented in the British monarchy, where the wives  of princes always automatically assumed their husband’s status. The government’s official legal justification was that Edward had voluntarily given  up his place in the succession, so the dignity of the crown required a clear public boundary between him and the rest of the dynasty.

However,    behind the dry legal language lay a clear political calculation. Queen Mary,  George VI, and the new Queen Elizabeth had fundamentally decided that Wallis Simpson would never receive a royal courtesy. For Edward, this was a crushing  blow. He could absorb the loss of his throne because he chose it, but he could not bear  the public humiliation of his wife.

For the next 35 years, until his death in 1972, he would  wage an exhausting and utterly futile campaign to have Wallis recognized as a royal highness. Yet, the family’s response  remained unyielding. And behind it stood one person, his mother. Historians still debate Queen Mary’s level of personal involvement  in drafting the 1937 decree.

 She was not a lawyer or the head of government,    and she didn’t sit down with the Lord Chancellor to write the text. However, all memoirs and internal court records agree on one thing. The new King George VI made no decisions regarding his brother’s titles  without deep consultations with his mother. Queen Mary viewed stripping Wallis  of the title as both right and necessary.

She wanted that door closed forever. Edward and Wallis married on June 3rd, 1937,  at the Château de Candé in France. Not a single member of the British royal family attended. They weren’t even invited,  as Queen Mary had made it clear that no one was to go. The wedding photographs captured only a small circle  of friends and a hired Anglican clergyman who defied his bishops to perform  the ceremony.

The couple found personal happiness, but completely lost their state  status. The newlyweds spent their honeymoon in a rented castle in Austria. There, Wallace discovered that the senior staff had been officially instructed to address her as “Your Grace” instead of “Your Royal Highness.” Wallace cried with humiliation,  and the Duke fumed.

Only 6 months after fleeing Great Britain, the state establishment continued to ruthlessly remind them of their new, marginalized position  outside the palace walls. After losing the throne and marrying the woman he loved,  the Duke of Windsor could have spent the next few years quietly, painting watercolors in Antibes,  riding horses in Austrian valleys, sending a polite Christmas card to Marlborough House, and waiting for the family’s forgiveness, which, given the circumstances, was never going to come,

   but at least remained theoretically possible. Instead, he chose a different path. In October 1937, just 4 months after their wedding,    the Duke and Duchess of Windsor visited Nazi Germany. The trip was billed as a fact-finding tour of working conditions. The couple met Adolf Hitler at his Berghof retreat.

Footage survives showing Wallace  curtsying to the Führer as he kissed her hand. Edward, at least once, gave what onlookers described as a Nazi-style salute, though historians still argue whether it was a full salute  or a partial wave. The visit was a massive propaganda gift to the Third Reich.

German newspapers framed the former British King-Emperor’s arrival    as proof that the great Anglo-Saxon democracy sympathized with National  Socialism. The British government and the entire royal family  were horrified. Queen Mary, judging by her correspondence, took it as a personal catastrophe.

Her outrage had deep roots. She had spent her entire adult life within a  dynasty that was nearly destroyed by anti-German sentiment during the First World War. The British royal family was  genetically German with the original surname Saxe-Coburg-Gotha. The war with the Kaiser made it intolerable.

 And in 1917, George V  was forced by public pressure to change the family name to Windsor, strip away all German titles,    and publicly prove that the British royal house was entirely British. Queen Mary supported her husband through this, even though it caused her a total rupture with her own German relatives, a heavy personal blow.

 Two  decades were spent rebuilding the monarchy’s image as the democratic head of a nation that defeated German militarism at an immense human cost. And now, her eldest son was shaking hands with a new  German dictator. When World War II broke out in September 1939, the security risk regarding the Duke of Windsor became critical.

As a former king, he held the rank of a British Army officer, but was living in France. After the fall of France in June 1940,    Edward and Wallis fled south, eventually making their way through Spain to Portugal. There, at a villa outside Lisbon,  they spent the summer of 1940 while German intelligence tried to convince them through intermediaries to stay  in Europe, hoping to use Edward for a potential peace settlement after Britain’s expected defeat.

This episode entered history as Operation Willi. The documents concerning this operation, captured by the Allies at the end of the war and later released as the Marburg  files, were a massive embarrassment for London. According to the  archives, German diplomats seriously counted on the Duke in a post-war settlement and offered him generous  financial incentives.

Edward himself made shocking statements during  this period, suggesting that heavy bombing of British cities could shorten the war and force Churchill’s government out of office. The Duke’s official biographer, Philip Ziegler, notes that these documents do not contain direct proof of formal treason or a written agreement to become  a puppet king.

However, they clearly prove his absolute political recklessness  and moral blindness, which the Nazis tried to exploit. In July 1940, Winston  Churchill solved the problem decisively. He appointed Edward governor of the Bahamas, effectively  exiling him to a Caribbean colony far away from the European front.

The couple spent the rest of the war there, with the Duke constantly  complaining about the heat, the staff, the food, and the quality of the cocktails. No letters from Queen Mary to her son survived from this period, but her stance was obvious.  She unwaveringly supported King George the VI and never reached out to her firstborn.

  The war years permanently confirmed the conclusion she had reached back  in December 1936. David had not only been the wrong king, he had proven to be a dangerous man  for his country. Following the war, the Duke and Duchess of Windsor began the second act  of their long and strange life.

They settled permanently in France, becoming  fixtures of cafe society, childless, jobless, and without any real role. The couple lived lavishly on Edward’s personal fortune  and a generous financial settlement George VI had arranged as part of the abdication. They also made money by selling their story.

  In 1951, Edward published his memoirs, A King’s Story, written with the help of American journalist Charles  Murphy. The book, which framed the abdication as a noble sacrifice for love, became a best-seller, though historians view it more as an exercise in self-justification  than an objective source.

Queen Mary read the memoirs, but her reaction remains unknown. She remained the matriarchal figurehead of the new royal family until her final days. In 1937, she even broke strict etiquette by personally attending  the coronation of her second son, George VI, despite the tradition that widows of previous sovereigns do  not attend the crowning of their successors.

Royal archives describe her presence in a  separate gallery of Westminster Abbey as a deliberate gesture of public support for the new ruler, sitting exactly where her eldest son was  supposed to stand. During World War II, Mary actively continued her duties, knitting for the troops and salvaging scrap metal.

She spent the war years at Badminton House in Gloucestershire, where her hosts found her incredibly energetic, formidably tidy, and completely uninterested in any conversation regarding her exiled son. She occasionally corresponded with Edward.  These letters were not cruel, but they lacked warmth, remaining models of strict Edwardian restraint.

 She wished him well on his birthdays and inquired about his health, but she wrote not as a grieving mother, but as a former family member  maintaining official politeness. Reconciliation efforts were futile. The Duke crossed the channel a few times after the war for funerals, most notably flying in for George VI funeral  in February 1952.

However, Edward did not see his mother privately as he had arrived without Wallace, whom the Queen still refused to receive, and neither side was  prepared to back down from their hardened positions. George VI died on February 6, 1952  after a long illness. The strain of the war years, the heavy burden of an unexpected  throne, and a lifetime chain-smoking habit cut him down at just 56.

His death broke Queen Mary far more than the previous abdication of  her firstborn. She had lost her husband and now three of her sons. The new sovereign was her 25-year-old granddaughter, Elizabeth II. Queen Mary herself  had only months to live. She died at Marlborough House on March 24th, 1953,  just 10 weeks before Elizabeth’s coronation.

Her final  instructions were uncompromising. The coronation must proceed on schedule regardless of her death, and the Duke and Duchess of Windsor were officially forbidden  from attending. A wish the new queen respected to the letter. For his mother’s funeral in 1953, the Duke of Windsor flew in from Paris  alone.

He stayed at Marlborough House for a few days, attended the service at St. George’s  Chapel, Windsor, where Mary was buried in the royal vault beside her husband. After  the service, he hosted a small dinner for the family and sat at the head of the table where his mother had once presided.

 According to staff, the Duke wept during  the service and looked like a man who had permanently lost any chance of ever being understood by his mother. His brother was dead, his sister was  gravely ill, his niece was queen, and he remained a lonely exile  and a stranger in the home of his childhood. The next morning,  he returned to Paris alone.

 Edward went to his grave 19 years later believing to his final days  that his mother had been cruel. Perhaps she was. A less institutional mother would have gone to Paris in 1937,    embraced her daughter-in-law, and let the throne look after itself. But a woman with such a soft character would never have been able to hold the British monarchy together  during the greatest upheavals of the 20th century.

Her great-granddaughter, Elizabeth II, would ultimately reign for 70 years, and the institution of the Crown, for which Mary sacrificed her own flesh and blood, survived World  Wars, the collapse of an empire, technological revolutions, and a string of future family scandals that made the 1936 crisis look like a parking ticket.

When staff cleared out Queen Mary’s bedroom at Marlborough House after her death,  they found a small framed photograph of David as a young man hidden deep inside a drawer. Mary had never shown it to anyone    and never brought it out into the light. But she had carefully kept it and dusted it through all 17 years of their estrangement.

The photograph lay beside her childhood rosary and the prayer book she used at  her husband’s funeral. She did not display it, but she did not destroy it, either. The Iron Queen simply kept the image  of her lost son behind closed doors. Thank you for watching this story to the end.