She was already there when he walked in. That was the first thing. She was already there sitting at the corner table with a cigarette and a coffee and the specific quality of a woman who has decided that wherever she is, that is where things are happening. Not performing this, simply being it the way certain people are certain things without effort or announcement.
Elvis stopped in the doorway. He had come to the Paramount Studios canteen because it was empty because the set had been running since 6:00 in the morning and the director had called lunch and Elvis had needed 20 minutes somewhere that did not require him to be Elvis Presley at full operational capacity.
The canteen at 2:00 in the afternoon was supposed to be empty. It was not empty. Ava Gardner looked up from her coffee. She looked at him the way she looked at most things, directly, without the social management that most people apply to eye contact, without the brief glance and the look away that constitutes ordinary human acknowledgement.
She just looked at him with the eyes that had been looking at things for 34 years and had learned somewhere in those years to see what was actually there. “Sit down,” she said. “You’re letting the light in.” He sat down. What happened in the next 40 minutes in that corner of the Paramount Studios canteen while the lot outside returned to its afternoon operations was a conversation that Elvis would carry for the rest of his life.
Not as a story he told, but as something interior, a fixed point he returned to without always knowing he was returning to it. 1957 was a complicated year to be Elvis Presley. From the outside, it did not look complicated. From the outside, 1957 looked like the logical continuation of something that had been building since 1954.
The records, the television appearances, the soldout shows, the specific quality of cultural phenomenon that happens when a sound arrives that is so new and so necessary that the culture reorganizes itself around it before anyone has quite decided what to do about the reorganization. From the inside, it felt different.
He had been famous for 3 years. 3 years is long enough to understand that the famous version of yourself and the actual version are not the same person. And that the gap widens with each passing month, and that the widening is something you either manage or something that manages you.
He had been watching the gap. He had not yet decided what to do about it. He was 22 years old and he was learning things that 22 year olds should not yet have to know. And he was learning them the way you learn things you are not ready for by absorbing them without the framework to process them. Carrying them forward until the framework arrived or until the carrying became its own kind of damage.
The canteen was empty because he needed it to be empty. Then it wasn’t. Ava Gardner had been famous since before Elvis knew what famous meant. She had come from nowhere particular, rural North Carolina, a tobacco farming family. The specific kind of nowhere that Hollywood had been importing its people from since the beginning, because nowhere in particular tends to produce people who are hungry in ways that somewhere in particular it does not.
She had arrived in Los Angeles at 18, and the camera had understood her before she understood herself, which was the way it worked for the ones who had it. The thing the camera saw was real, was there before the camera found it, and the camera simply confirmed what was already present.
She had spent 15 years becoming what she was, which was in 1957 one of the most famous women in the world and one of the loneliest people on the Paramount lot on a Tuesday afternoon. Frank Sinatra had been her third husband. The marriage had lasted 2 years. The divorce had been finalized 8 months ago. Neither of these facts communicated anything accurate about the relationship, about its specific gravity, the way it had organized everything around itself while it lasted, the way certain things leave a shape in you when they go that does not fill back in. Ava had been in three marriages. She understood at a level of clinical precision that she had earned through experience what the end of a marriage felt like. This one felt different. She had come to the canteen because it was empty and she needed the empty and because she had been carrying something since morning that required
somewhere quiet to carry it. Then the door opened. She looked up. The young man standing in the doorway had the specific quality of someone who does not yet know what to do with what they have, which is a quality that disappears quickly and that is therefore when you catch it worth looking at.
She had seen it before. She had seen it on a face she was trying not to think about. At approximately the same age, in approximately the same doorway expression of someone who has arrived somewhere they did not quite expect to arrive and are deciding whether to stay. Sit down, she said. You’re letting the light in.
They talked about the kind of things people talk about when they have decided to be honest without quite announcing the decision. He talked about the gap, not in those words. He did not have those words yet, but around it, circling the thing without landing on it, the way you circle something you have not yet found the language for.
Advertisements
About the distance between the shows and the rooms afterward, about the feeling of performing something and then returning to yourself and finding the return more difficult than it had been the time before. She listened not with the performed detention of someone being polite with the actual thing.
The listening of someone who recognizes the territory from the inside, who has been in this particular landscape and knows its specific features and is not going to pretend otherwise. You know what the problem is? She said it was not a question. He looked at her. The problem is that it works. She said, “If it didn’t work, you’d have somewhere to put the doubt.
You’d be able to say, “Well, I’m not sure this is right, and look, here’s the evidence, but it works. The shows work, the records work, the audience works, and so the doubt has nowhere to go.” She drew on her cigarette. It just accumulates. Elvis was quiet for a moment. “How do you deal with it?” he said. Ava looked at him.
She leaned forward slightly, the movement of someone who has decided that what they are about to say requires a different proximity. Her hand moved toward the ashtray on the table between them, and she set the cigarette on its edge, and her fingers came to rest on the table an inch from his hand, and neither of them acknowledged this, and neither of them moved.
“I haven’t figured that out yet,” she said. “I’ll let you know.” She looked at his face. She looked at it the way she had looked at it from across the room when he walked in directly without the management seeing what was there. And what was there under the famous face under the three years of being looked at by everyone and understood by almost no one was the face of a kid from Mississippi who had grown up wanting something and gotten it and found that the getting did not resolve the wanting.
She recognized it. She had loved a man who wore that face. The thought arrived before she could redirect it, and she made a decision that she would later be uncertain about. She let it arrive. Let it land. Let what was true be true for a moment without performing a version of herself that had moved past it.
“You remind me of Frank,” she said. The canteen was very quiet. She had not planned to say it. She understood this immediately, understood that the sentence had been in her somewhere and had found its exit before she had decided to open the door. She watched it arrive in the space between them and stay there the way certain true things stay.
She watched what happened to his face when it landed. He did not fill the silence, did not deflect, did not smile, did not produce any of the available social responses to a statement that could be received as compliment or provocation or simply noise. He looked at her. His eyes, which were the specific blue that photographs had been trying to capture for three years without quite getting it right, were on her face with the quality of attention she had noticed since he sat down, the actual listening kind, and she felt the attention with the specific acuity of someone who has spent years being looked at and can tell the difference between that and being seen. The silence stretched. She was not uncomfortable in it. God help you, she said. He asked. Not immediately. There was more silence
first. The silence of someone deciding whether the question was the right question, whether the asking of it would cost something that should not be spent. Then, in which way? Ava looked at the cigarette in the ashtray. She picked it up, turned it in her fingers, did not bring it to her lips.
He had it too, she said. Whatever you have, that thing where people look at you and feel something they weren’t feeling before. She paused. It’s a gift. It’s also a She stopped. The people who have it spend their whole lives being wanted for it and wanting something back that has nothing to do with it. She set the cigarette down again.
And those two things don’t resolve. She looked at him. Frank never figured out how to make them resolve. I don’t know if it’s possible to figure that out. A pause that have a specific weight in it. I hope you do. Elvis was still looking at her. Is that why it ended? He said with Frank. She looked at him for a moment.
There are questions that arrive in a conversation and change its temperature. Not because they cross a clearly drawn line, but because they go somewhere the conversation had been circling without landing. Elvis had asked one of those questions. He had asked it with the directness of someone who has decided the question is worth the cost.
And he held her gaze while he asked it. And she understood that the wanting to know was genuine, not social curiosity, but something more specific, something that had been building across 40 minutes of the most honest conversation she had had in recent memory. She made a decision. We ended, she said, because the things we needed from each other were the same things.
And two people who need the same thing don’t always She stopped, started again. Sometimes what looks like love is just recognition. Two people seeing themselves in each other and mistaking the relief of being seen for something that can last. The canteen held this. And was it? Elvis said. Love. Ava looked at him. Something crossed her face that she did not manage.
The specific expression of someone for whom a word has arrived and is being held before being spoken. The expression of someone treating language with the respect it deserves when the thing being named is large. Yes, she said without qualification, without decoration, it was love. It was also, she stopped, it was also not enough, which is the thing nobody tells you that it can be real and genuine and the biggest thing you have ever felt and still not be enough.
That those two facts can be simultaneously true. She paused. Frank knew that. I knew that. We knew it about each other and we tried anyway. And we were right about the love and right about the not enough. both at the same time. Elvis was quiet. Frank’s name was not said again. It did not need to be. It was present in the room the way certain things are present.
Not spoken, not pointed to, but there shaping the air around everything that followed. A third presence at the corner table of the Paramount Studios canteen on a Tuesday afternoon in 1957. Ava leaned forward. She reached toward the ashtray and her hand moved slowly with the unhurried deliberateness of someone who is aware of a movement while making it and her fingers came to rest on the table an inch from his hand.
Neither of them acknowledged this. Neither of them moved. The inch remained an inch. It had been that inch for 15 minutes now, and it would remain that inch. And both of them knew it would remain that inch. And the knowing was not relief exactly, but was something adjacent to relief.
The specific quality of two people who have arrived at a limit they are not going to cross and made peace with the not crossing made the maintained distance into its own kind of presence. From the service corridor, a sound, a dolly on concrete, someone moving equipment back to the afternoon shoot, coming closer, then past, then fading.
Neither of them had moved. The set assistant, who appeared in the canteen doorway at 2:43, later described the moment as the most uncomfortable interruption of her career, not because of anything she witnessed that was inappropriate, but because of the quality of what she interrupted, which she could not name precisely, but which communicated itself to her immediately as something that had been in the middle of being something, and had now been prevented from finishing the being. “Mr.
Presley,” she said. “They’re ready for you.” Elvis looked up. He looked at the assistant and then he looked back at Ava. And what was in his face in that moment. The assistant described this 30 years later with the specificity of someone who had spent 30 years occasionally thinking about it was the expression of a man who has been somewhere and is being asked to leave it before he is finished being there.
“All right,” he said. He stood. He looked at Ava for a moment. “Thank you,” he said. He said it the way he said things when he meant them completely with the flatness of sincerity that does not require decoration. Ava looked up at him. “Don’t let them change you,” she said. It was almost the same thing Bate Davis would say to him 3 years later in a different room, which was perhaps not a coincidence, but was instead the specific wisdom available to women of a certain experience about men of a certain quality, the wisdom that recognizes the thing worth protecting and names it before the thing is gone.” Elvis nodded once. He walked out. Ava sat at the corner table. She picked up her coffee, which had gone cold while they talked. She looked at the doorway he had gone through. She looked at the ashtray. She looked at the table where
his hand had been. She sat there for a while. Outside the lot returned to its afternoon operations, the trucks, the set noise, the specific organized chaos of a studio in production, the machinery of manufacturing a particular version of reality and sending it out into the world.
Ava Gardner sat at the corner table in the empty canteen and finished her cold coffee and did not go back to any of it for another 20 minutes. The set assistant in her account of the afternoon noted one other thing. She had come back through the canteen at 3:15 after returning Elvis to the set to retrieve a clipboard she had left on one of the tables.
Ava Gardner was still at the corner table. She was looking at the doorway. She was not doing anything else.
