October 28th, 1956. CBS Studio 50, New York City. Elvis Presley is backstage before his second appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show. Journalists are gathered in the corridor. A doctor and a nurse from the New York City Department of Health are standing ready. Elvis rolls up his left sleeve, looks sideways at the needle with that half smile that had already appeared on the cover of every teenage girl’s magazine in America, and lets Assistant Commissioner of Health Harold First administer the polio vaccine into his arm in front of everyone who cared to watch. Moments later, he walked out on stage, 21 years old, the most famous person in America, and sang Hound Dog, Don’t Be Cruel, and Love Me Tender to the same country that had watched 60 million people tune in to his first Sullivan
appearance 6 weeks earlier. The photograph of the vaccine being administered was sent out across the country by newspapers the following morning, and somewhere in the offices of the New York City Department of Health, Health Commissioner Dr. Leona Baumgartner read the reports and said three words about what Elvis had done.
He is setting a fine example for the youth of the country. She was more right than she could have known at the time. To understand what that October evening actually accomplished, you have to understand how bad things had gotten, not with polio, but with the vaccine that had been developed to stop it.
Polio had been ravaging the United States for decades. At the height of its spread in the late 1940s, it paralyzed an average of more than 35,000 Americans every year. In 1952, the worst single year on record, 3,200 people died from it, and 21,000 were left with some degree of paralysis. The disease moved through communities like a slow disaster, striking most severely at children who had the least immunity and the most exposure through contact with other children in schools and public spaces.
Parents in cities that experienced outbreaks found themselves shutting pools, canceling summer activities, keeping children indoors during the months when polio was most active. The terror was genuine, and the measures were desperate because the disease had no cure and no reliable pattern to its spread.
In 1955, Jonas Salk announced the completion of his vaccine. Physician and epidemiologist Thomas Francis Jr. declared it safe and effective. It was, by any measure, one of the most significant medical achievements of the 20th century. A working solution to a disease that had paralyzed tens of thousands of American children every year.
What followed the announcement should have been straightforward. Vaccinate the population, eliminate the disease. What followed instead was a crisis of public confidence that nearly undid the entire effort. The Cutter incident happened in April of 1955, the same year the vaccine was introduced.
A manufacturing error at Cutter Laboratories in California had resulted in improperly inactivated vaccine that actually caused polio in the people who received it. 40,000 people contracted the disease from the contaminated batches. About 200 were left with some degree of paralysis. 10 died. The incident was quickly identified, and the contaminated lots were withdrawn, but the damage to public trust was enormous.
Parents who had been preparing to vaccinate their children stopped. Teenagers who were at high risk and could make their own decisions about whether to seek a shot stayed away. Then, Walter Winchell made things worse. Winchell was a gossip columnist and radio commentator whose audience numbered in the tens of millions. In 1954, before the Salk vaccine had even been officially approved, he had gone on radio and told his listeners that the polio vaccine, as he put it, may be a killer.
He had no medical training and no specific evidence for the claim. Jonas Salk himself had to issue a public correction, but Winchell’s reach was enormous and the fear he had stoked was not easily undone. By the time Elvis Presley walked backstage at CBS Studio 50 in October of 1956, immunization levels among American teenagers had dropped to 0.
6%, not 60%, 0.6. Out of every thousand American teenagers who should have been vaccinated against a disease that paralyzed tens of thousands of children every year, fewer than seven had gotten the shot. The New York City Department of Health had been working for years to close that gap.
They had run campaigns, published information, worked with schools and community organizations. None of it had moved the number. The demographic they were trying to reach, teenagers, had proven systematically resistant to the kinds of messaging that worked on adults. Doctors explaining safety statistics did not move them.
Public health officials posting notices did not move them. What moved them in 1956 was exactly one thing, and the New York City Health Department understood what it was. They asked Elvis Presley to get a vaccine in front of reporters. He agreed. The arrangement was made with the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis and coordinated with the Teens Against Polio campaign, a grassroots advocacy organization that had been working to promote vaccination among young people through methods that included a somewhat aggressive courtship policy. Young women in some areas had adopted a no shots, no dates approach to their social lives, refusing to spend time with unvaccinated partners. They also organized sock hops, dances where admission required proof of vaccination. These were teenagers trying to reach teenagers, and they were more effective than anything the official health
establishment had managed. But they were still operating at the community level. They needed something national. On October 28th, 1956, they got it. The procedure itself took moments. Elvis rolled up his sleeve, smiled at the reporters, let the needle go in, and walked out on stage. The photograph that resulted, Dr.
Advertisements
Baumgartner holding his arm as Dr. First administers the shot, Elvis looking sideways with that characteristic expression that managed to be simultaneously cool and approachable, was published in hundreds of newspapers across the country. The story ran the following morning with the quote from Commissioner Baumgartner about the fine example being set for the youth of the country.
The National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis later offered photographs signed by Elvis to any fan club that could prove all of its members had been vaccinated. In addition to the backstage moment, Elvis recorded a public service announcement for the foundation in which he stated directly that the fight against polio is as tough as it ever was.
What happened to vaccination rates in the months that followed has been documented by medical historians and public health researchers. Within 6 months of Elvis’s public vaccination, immunization rates among American youth had risen from 0.6% to approximately 80%. The annual incidence of polio in the United States decreased by nearly 90% between 1950 and 1960.
Between 1955 and 1957 alone, the years immediately surrounding Elvis’s involvement, polio cases dropped from 28,985 to 5,485. By 1963, the New York City Health Commissioner of that era announced that vaccination had reduced the number of new cases in the city to zero. University of Bristol Professor Stephen Mawdsley, who published academic research on this period in the Journal of Cultural and Social History, was careful to note that Elvis alone did not accomplish this.
The real game-changer, he argued, came from the teenagers themselves, from the Teens Against Polio campaign, from the door-to-door canvassing, from the Salk cops and the no shots, no dates policy, from the work of thousands of young people who understood their own demographic that adult public health officials did not. Elvis was a catalyst, not the entire engine.
The combination of his visible participation and the grassroots campaign that surrounded it was what produced the numbers. But catalysts matter. 0.6% to 80% is not a small change. 35,000 people paralyzed every year is not a small number. And the specific problem the health department had been unable to solve, reaching teenagers who had stopped listening to the official communication channels, was solved, at least partially, by a 21-year-old from Tupelo, Mississippi, rolling up his left sleeve backstage at a television studio and letting a doctor from the city’s health department do their job. The photograph is in the CBS photo archive and in the New York City Municipal Archives. It shows Elvis at the moment of injection looking sideways at the needle with the expression of someone who is entirely at ease.
Dr. Baumgartner is holding his arm. Dr. First is administering the shot. A crowd of reporters is visible in the background. The most famous person in America is getting a needle in his arm in a backstage corridor and he is smiling about it because he agreed to do it and he is the kind of person who does the things he agrees to do.
He walked out on stage immediately after and performed for a country that had no idea what had just happened in the hallway. The song he opened with was Hound Dog. The number of teenagers who got vaccinated in the following six months was enough to change the trajectory of an epidemic. No other single individual had that kind of impact on a public health outcome in 20th century American history.
That is not a promotion or an exaggeration. That is what the medical literature documents. The photograph is on the internet. Find it. Look at the expression on his face. That is the expression of someone who understood that being the most famous person in America was occasionally useful for something other than selling records.
