October, 1957. Route 66, the bus depot on the east edge of Gallup, New Mexico. A blind man sits on a bench outside the depot with his back against the warm adobe wall and his face turned a little toward the sound of the highway. He is Navajo. His name is Raymond Begay and 12 years ago, he was a United States Marine.
He left both of his eyes in the black volcanic sand of a Pacific island in the spring of 1945. And he came home to learn that the war had taken more than his sight. It had taken the years a young man needs to hold on to his land. And the land was gone and the sheep were gone and the old people who could have told him exactly how it all slipped away were already in the ground.
He does not call it begging. A Begay does not beg. He splices rope and men’s harness by feel for the freight men who come through the depot and they drop their coins into a coffee tin by his boot. And he calls it work because it is work. This morning a man is going to try to run him off that bench for good.
And a tall man in a tan Stetson waiting on a tank of gas across the lot is going to see the whole thing happen. Here is the story. Raymond Begay was born in 1924 on the high red land out past Window Rock in a hogan his grandmother had blessed. And he grew up the way the people had grown up for a long time before him. With the sheep.
He learned the country by walking it. He learned which washes ran water and which only promised to. And he learned the silver from his grandmother who made conchos and bridles and squash blossom necklaces with a little set of tools and a tree stump and her own two hands.
And who told him that silver, like a man, is only ever worth what it is willing to carry. He was 19 in the winter of 1943 when he walked the 12 miles into Gallup and put his name down for the Marines. A lot of the young men did. The recruiters did not always know what to make of them at first and then they learned, the way everybody of actually learned, that there were no better Marines in that whole ocean than the young men who came down off that high dry land where nothing is ever handed to you and the wind takes back whatever you don’t tie down. He went to the Pacific. He does not talk about the Pacific. There is one island he was on at the very end, a small one, eight square miles of black sand and tunnels where the Marines went ashore in February of 1945
and did not stop bleeding for 36 days. On the 19th of those days, a shell came in close enough that the man beside Raymond was simply gone and the light went out of Raymond’s world and never came back on. He was 20 years old. They gave him a Purple Heart in a hospital where he could hear the ocean but could no longer see it.
And when there was nothing more they could do for his eyes, they sent him home. Home was not there anymore. His mother and his father had both passed while he was overseas within a season of each other. The land their family had run for three generations had been tied up in a trader’s debt that nobody had thought to mention to a boy in a foxhole.
And by the time Raymond came feeling his way down off the train at Gallup, the debt had eaten the grazing rights and the sheep had been sold off and scattered. And there was nothing left to go home to but the wind and the bare place where the Hogan used to stand.
He kept two things out of all of it. He kept his dog tags, USMC stamped cold into the metal, on a length of string around his neck. And he kept one silver concha his grandmother had made, the last of all that silver, worn smooth now from his thumb passing over it 10,000 times. He carried it in his shirt pocket over his heart.
And when the nights got long, he would take it out and read the stamps in it with his fingers. And it was the closest thing he had left to seeing. By 1957, he had been at the Gallup Depot for years. He had a corner of a freight shed to sleep in that the yard boss pretended not to know about. He mended what the freight men brought him.
And he took his coins, and he bought his coffee and his beans. And he sat on the bench outside the depot in the daytime with his face to the highway. He was about as close to all right as a blind man with no land and no people left can get. He was not bothering a single soul. Saturday morning, the bench, the warm wall at his back.
The man who has decided to run him off is named Vernon Slade, and he owns the lunchroom inside the depot. And he has been wanting that bench cleared for a good while. A blind Navajo with a coffee can is not, in Vernon Slade’s professional opinion, good for the kind of trade he is trying to build. The buses stop.
People step off hungry. And the first thing some of them see is a beggar. Slade has complained to the yard boss twice and gotten nowhere. So this morning, he has decided to handle it himself. He comes out onto the platform with two of his countermen trailing behind him for an audience. “All right,” he says loud, so the whole platform can hear it.
Advertisements
“Up. You’ve warmed my customer’s bench long enough. We don’t need your kind out here turning stomachs. Go on, take your can, and clear off.” Raymond Begay does not move, and he does not raise his voice. “I mend rope,” he says. “I’m not asking anybody for anything.” “You’re an eyesore is what you are.
” Vernon Slayton is enjoying his audience now. He nudges the coffee tin with the toe of his shoe, and the coins go ringing and rolling out across the platform planks. And a couple of the waiting passengers laugh the way people laugh when they are uncomfortable. And a man with a little power has just told them it’s all right to “Pick up your money and go, or I’ll have you carried off.
” And across the lot by a battered truck at the single gas pump, a tall man in a tan Stetson and a canvas ranch coat sets down the cup of coffee he has just been handed and starts walking. He is 50 years old in the fall of 1957. He has spent a good part of his life on Marine Corps bases for one picture or another and in hospital wards, shaking the hands of men who came back off that same ocean in worse shape than they went out on it.
He saw the string around the blind man’s neck from 40 ft away. He has seen a thousand of them. He knows exactly what USMC stamped into a dog tag means and exactly what it costs and exactly who paid. He does not hurry. He crosses the lot and he comes up onto the platform. And the people part for him without quite knowing why, and he walks past Vernon Slade like Slade is a fence post.
And he crouches down in front of the bench, and he starts picking the scattered coins up off the planks one at a time, slow, and dropping them back into the coffee tin. The platform has gone very quiet. “Hey,” Vernon Slade says. “Hey now, friend, that’s between me and” And then the tall man stands up, all the way up with the coffee tin in his hand, and turns around.
And Slade gets a good look at his face. And whatever he had lined up to say goes out of him like air out of a cut tire. “You dumped this man’s money out on the ground,” the tall man says. He is not loud. He does not need to be. In front of all these people, a man who left both his eyes on a black sand island in the Pacific so that you could stand here and run a lunch room.
He sets the coffee tin back down on the bench by Raymond’s boot, gentle, exactly where it had been. Now, you’re going to tell this Marine you’re sorry. Then you’re going to walk back inside, and you are going to leave this man be on this bench for the rest of his natural life. Are we clear, you and I? Vernon Slade looks back at his two countermen for some help, and finds both of them studying their own shoes.
He gets out something with the word sorry buried somewhere in the middle of it, and he goes back inside, and the screen door bangs shut behind him, and it is over. Where are you watching from? Drop your state in the comments. I want to see how far this story reaches. The tall man sits down on the bench.
Raymond Begay has not said one word through any of it. He sits there with his blind face turned toward the sound of this stranger, reading him the only way he has left to read anybody. “I didn’t need that,” Raymond says finally. “But I thank you for picking up the tin. You were a Marine a while back.
What island?” Raymond tells him. The tall man is quiet for a moment, the kind of quiet that carries more in it than talk does. “I made some pictures about that ocean,” he says. “I never once had to do the thing you did out there. Men like you are the reason men like me get to play at it on a back lot.
” He looks at the dog tags on the string and at the worn place on the shirt pocket where something gets taken out and put back 10,000 times. “Where do you live, Marine?” “Around.” “That’s not an answer.” So Raymond tells him the rest of it plainly, the way a man tells a story whose ending he made his peace with a long time ago.
The mother and father gone, the land gone behind a debt he never signed his name to, the sheep scattered to who knows where, the freight shed, the bench. He does not tell it for pity. He tells it because the man asked him straight and because there is something in the man’s voice that has earned the hearing of it.
The tall man sits with that a while. Then he stands. “You stay right here,” he says. “I’ll be a couple hours.” He’s back in under three. He has been to the bank and to a realtor and out to a small adobe house on a quiet street on the west side of Gallup, a house with a porch that faces the morning, four rooms, a good well, and a cottonwood tree in the yard.
A place a widow had been trying to sell for the better part of a year. He paid $3,200 for it in cash. He had the deed drawn up that same afternoon. And there is a name written on the line where the owner’s name is supposed to go. It is not his name. It is Raymond Begay’s. He comes back to the bench, and he puts the folded deed into Raymond’s two hands, and he tells him what it is.
And for the first time all morning, the blind man’s steady face comes apart. “I can’t take a house from a stranger.” Raymond says, and his voice is not steady now. “I can’t ever pay it back. I’ve got nothing to pay it back with.” “It isn’t a loan.” The tall man crouches back down in front of the bench, so the two of them are level.
“Listen to me, Marine. You went to that island when you were just a boy. You gave it everything a man has got, and a little bit more besides. And this country took your eyes for it, and let your family’s land slip away while you were gone bleeding for it, and never paid you one honest dollar for any of that.
That right there is a debt. It has just been owed to the wrong man all these years.” He folds Raymond’s fingers closed around the deed. “This is not charity. This is back pay, and it is long, long overdue. You take the house. You take it because it is yours, and it was always going to be yours, and it has just taken this long to finally find its way home to you.
” He had stopped at the trading post, too. There is an account standing there now in Raymond’s name, paid a full year ahead for whatever it is a man needs. And he has arranged with a boy from the freight yard, a good kid who had always liked the blind Marine anyway, to look in on him every morning and read him whatever the mail brings.
Raymond Begay sits on the bench holding the deed to a house he has never seen and never will see. And he turns his blind face up toward the man and he says, “I have to know the name of the man who did this so I can say it, so I can keep it.” The tall man is already up, already turning back toward his truck.
“Tell them a Marine stopped to fix your rope,” he says. But the boy at the gas pump, who has been standing frozen by the pump for 20 minutes now with his jaw hanging open, finally gets it out. “That’s John Wayne,” he says to the whole platform, to nobody at all. “That’s John Wayne.” The tall man does not turn around.
He lifts one hand loose and easy, the way you lift a hand to wave off a thing that doesn’t need saying out loud. And he climbs up into his battered truck and he points it west on 66 toward Arizona, toward his ranch out past Stanfield, and the dust comes up gold behind him in the long afternoon light and hangs there a good while after he’s gone.
Raymond Begay never saw the truck leave. He sat on that bench with his thumb moving over his grandmother’s silver concha and the deed folded in his other hand. And he turned his face toward the west, toward the sound of the engine getting smaller and smaller for a long time after there was nothing left to hear.
Have you ever had the one thing you were sure you had lost forever? A home, a place, the plain right to sit somewhere and not be run off of it. Handed back to you by a stranger who would not even stay long enough to let you say his name? It does something to a man. It takes him a long while to believe it, even with his own hands.
Raymond Begay lived in that little adobe house on the west side of Gallup for 29 years. The boy from the freight yard grew up and never once stopped looking in on him. And he brought his own children around, and they called the blind Marine grandfather, even though he was no blood of theirs, because that is what he had become to them.
Raymond mended their harness and their boots by feel, and he taught the oldest one a little silver work on his grandmother’s old stump. With his grandmother’s old tools, laying his hands over the boy’s hands to show him how. The same way she had once laid her hands over his. He had a porch that faced the morning, and he sat out on it every day of his life.
And not one living soul ever again told him to move along. John Wayne drove on to Arizona that afternoon and made his pictures and lived out his life, and he never once spoke of the blind Marine at the Gallup depot. Not to a reporter, not in an interview, not in any letter that anybody ever turned up. Vernon Slade told a cleaned-up version of it in his lunch room for years, one where he came off quite a bit better than he actually had.
And truth be told, that is most of how the story ever got out into the world at all. The house is still standing. Drive the old Route 66 through the west side of Gallup, on past where the trading posts used to be, and on a quiet street under a big cottonwood, you will find a small adobe house with a porch that faces the morning sun.
Go inside and on the wall by the window there is a framed document. It is the original deed. October 1957. The house and the lot conveyed to Raymond Begaye. There is no buyer’s name written anywhere on the page. He would not let them write it down. And beside the deed in the very same frame behind the very same glass hangs a length of worn string with a set of dog tags on it.
USMC stamped cold into the metal and one silver concha rubbed smooth as creek water along one edge. Smooth from a blind man’s thumb passing over it every single night for the rest of a long and quiet life. A man reading with his fingers. The only two things the world was never once able to take away from him. The morning sun comes up over Gallup the way it has come up for a hundred years and it crosses that porch and comes through that window and lies for a little while on the deed and the dog tags and the worn silver all three of them together. Then it moves along and the day gets going and out on the old road the trucks run west toward Arizona the way they always have. If this story reached you tonight, do me one favor. Pass it on. Share it with a veteran in your life. And if you happen to know one who came home hurt
and got forgotten by the rest of us, go and sit with him a while. And go ahead and hit that subscribe button if you haven’t yet because there are more Duke stories coming because they don’t make men like John Wayne anymore.
