The New York papers called it a romance. Janis Joplin and Joe Namath. The queen of rock and roll and Broadway Joe. The girl with the feather boa and the quarterback with the fur coat. The voice that stopped 7,000 people cold at Monterey and the arm that delivered the biggest upset in Super Bowl history.
The papers were exaggerating. The reality was a meeting. Maybe a date or two. A moment in New York in late 1969 when two of the most famous people in America briefly occupied the same room and found each other genuinely interesting. But here is the thing about the papers being wrong.
The papers being wrong about the scale of it doesn’t make the meeting less interesting. It makes it more interesting. Because what happened when these two people actually met, what they actually were to each other even briefly, is a better story than the romance the gossip columns invented. This is that story. November 1969, New York City.
Janis Joplin was in New York for a run of performances. The Cosmic Blues Band tour. The year had been difficult. The reviews mixed, the band not finding what Big Brother had. But New York received her the way New York always received her. With the specific electricity of a city that recognized something real when it arrived.
On November 27th, Thanksgiving Day, she had been at Madison Square Garden watching the Rolling Stones and had jumped onto Tina Turner’s stage during Land of 1,000 Dances. That moment is its own story. The aftermath. The tour manager’s description of her at the side of the stage drunk and screaming is also its own story.
But the story that the newspapers got hold of happened a few weeks later in December. Joe Namath was there. Joe Namath in late 1969. He was 26 years old. He had guaranteed a Super Bowl victory in January of that year against the Baltimore Colts, who were 17-point favorites in what was supposed to be the most lopsided game in championship football history, and he had delivered.
The New York Jets won Super Bowl III. Joe Namath became the most famous athlete in America overnight and remained the most famous athlete in America every day after that. He was not famous in the ordinary athlete way. He was famous in the way that 1969 New York required, as a celebrity who moved between worlds, who showed up at the right places, who was photographed with the right people, whose name appeared in columns that were not the sports pages.
He wore a fur coat. He had a llama rug in his apartment. He appeared in commercials for pantyhose. He was, by every available measure, the most glamorous athlete in America at a time when glamour in sports was not yet the norm. He was also, by everyone who knew him, genuinely interested in people. Not performing interest, actually interested.
The specific quality of someone who had come from Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania, not a glamorous origin, and had arrived in New York and found the whole thing genuinely fascinating. The meeting, the specific circumstances are not fully documented. A party, a bar, a mutual introduction through the specific New York social infrastructure of late 1969.
The world where rock and roll and sports and film and television and fashion all occupied the same few square miles of Manhattan and occasionally occupied the same rooms. Myra Friedman was Janis’s publicist. She was also, by the time of these events, one of Janis’s closest friends and confidants, the woman who would write the biography Buried Alive after Janis died, which remains one of the most honest accounts of who Janis Joplin actually was, Friedman described the New York period of late 1969 as one where Janis was, despite the difficult year, genuinely alive in the way that New York made her alive. The city suited something in her that San Francisco, for all its love of her, could not fully satisfy. And in that alive period, in that city, she met Joe Namath. What actually happened when they met? Janis Joplin walked into rooms and
said what she thought. This was not an affectation. It was not the cultivated provocateur performing for an audience. It was simply how she operated. The inability to manage the gap between what she actually thought and what she said, which was both her greatest quality as a performer and occasionally alarming as a social presence.
Joe Namath was used to being the most interesting person in any room. He had been the most interesting person in rooms for 3 years. Athletes, celebrities, socialites, musicians, he had met all of them and they had all in some way deferred to the specific gravity of his fame. Janis Joplin did not defer, not out of hostility, out of the simple fact that she operated by a completely different set of social rules than the ones Joe Namath was used to navigating.
The rules of the Haight-Ashbury scene, of the Port Arthur wound, of someone who had been told for years that she was wrong and had developed, as a survival mechanism, a complete indifference to conventional social hierarchies. She talked to him the way she talked to everyone, directly, with genuine curiosity, without performing interest or managing distance.
By everyone’s account, he found this entirely disarming. The newspapers, New York in 1969, had gossip columns. The gossip columns had photographers and informants in every room where famous people gathered. When Janis Joplin and Joe Namath appeared in the same locations more than once, which they did across the December weeks, the gossip infrastructure assembled them into a narrative.
Advertisements
They were romantically linked. Broadway Joe and the queen of rock and roll. The juxtaposition was irresistible for people whose job was to write irresistible juxtapositions. Myra Friedman later characterized the coverage as exaggerated beyond a meeting and a date or two. That is the honest account.
A meeting, maybe a date or two, but here is what’s more interesting than the romance the columns invented. 1969 was the year Joe Namath guaranteed the impossible and delivered it. It was also the year Janis Joplin was named possibly the best female voice of her generation by Rolling Stone, played Woodstock, lost Otis Redding 3 years after his death still felt recent, watched the Cosmic Blues Band struggle with what it was supposed to be, and spent the last weeks of the year in New York trying to figure out what came next. Two people, both 26, both at the absolute peak of what fame looked like in America in 1969, both from unlikely places. Namath from Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania. Joplin from Port Arthur, Texas. Both had arrived in the same city and become, through entirely different paths, the most visible versions of themselves. Both of them, by the
accounts of people who knew them, were in real life more complicated and more interesting than the public versions of themselves that the media had constructed. Namath was smarter and more thoughtful than the fur coat suggested. Joplin was funnier and more precise than the banshee wail suggested.
In a New York room in December 1969, they found each other out. Janis left New York and went to Brazil in early 1970. She had met David Nehaus, the man who would give her the longest stretch of ordinary life she had ever experienced, and the story with Namath became the kind of story that acquires slightly different shapes as it’s told over the years.
Joe Namath continued being Joe Namath. He continued guaranteeing things and occasionally delivering them. He aged into one of the most recognizable figures in American sports history, the kind of famous that lasts because it was attached to a real moment in time. Super Bowl 3, January 1969, the upset that rewrote what professional football could be. He is still alive.
He is in his 80s. Janis Joplin died in October 1970. She was 27 years old. Here is what makes the New York gossip column story more interesting than the romance it invented. In late 1969, New York contained both of them simultaneously. The most famous athlete in America and the most famous female rock singer in America, both 26, both at their absolute peak, briefly occupying the same rooms.
They were interesting to each other. That much is documented, not in the gossip columns, but in the accounts of the people who were there. Not because of the fur coat and the feather boa, because Namath was smarter than his image and Joplin was funnier than her image, and the specific combination of two people who both operated at a level of fame that almost nobody in any room could match.
Finding each other in a New York December and being genuinely surprised by what they found. The papers said romance. The reality was something rarer. Two people briefly seeing each other clearly in New York in 1969 before everything that came next. Here is what this story asks you. When did you meet someone from a completely different world than yours? Someone you would never have met in the ordinary course of your life and discover that the categories that had separated you were wrong.
Janis Joplin was the queen of rock and roll. Joe Namath was Broadway Joe. The gossip columns put them together and called it a romance because that was the only vocabulary they had for two famous people in the same room. The real story is simpler. Two people from Pennsylvania and Texas who had both arrived in New York and become famous in entirely different ways found each other genuinely interesting.
The papers got the headline wrong. The meeting was real. And in late 1969 for a few December weeks, two of the most famous people in America briefly shared the same city and saw each other more clearly than the gossip columns could explain. She went to Brazil. He went to the next season. She died in October 1970. He is still here. Subscribe.
The next story goes somewhere nobody has taken you before.
